An Extraordinary Succession: The Resignation of Pope Benedict XVI and the Dawn of the Francis Pontificate

Introduction: An Unprecedented Moment in Modern Papal History

On the morning of February 11, 2013, the world was met with a piece of news so unexpected that it was initially met with disbelief. Pope Benedict XVI, born Joseph Alois Ratzinger, announced his intention to resign from the papacy, effective February 28 of that year.1 The announcement, delivered in Latin during a routine consistory of cardinals, sent shockwaves through the Catholic Church and beyond.2 The gravity of the moment was underscored by the initial confusion; some present, including Cardinal Walter Brandmüller, thought it might be a "carnival joke".2 This reaction was understandable, as the papacy in the modern era had become synonymous with a lifelong commitment, a ministry held from election until death.2 The resignation of a pope was, for most of the world, an unimaginable event.5

This act set the stage for the election of his successor, Cardinal Jorge Mario Bergoglio of Argentina, who took the name Pope Francis.2 The transition from Benedict XVI, the 265th pope, to Francis was therefore not a typical succession following a period of mourning, but a historical anomaly of the highest order.6 The extraordinary nature of this succession lies in a confluence of three unprecedented factors. First, the

reason for the resignation was a voluntary act of conscience rooted in a personal assessment of declining physical and mental strength, a stark departure from the historical precedents of papal renunciations, which were almost exclusively driven by external political crises or profound incompetence.2 Second, the

consequences of the resignation were entirely novel, leading to the improvisation of the "Pope Emeritus" title and the subsequent, uncharted reality of two living popes—one reigning, one retired—cohabiting within the walls of the Vatican.9 Finally, the

implications of this decision have irrevocably altered the perception of the papacy itself, posing fundamental questions about the nature and demands of the Petrine ministry in the 21st century.11 This report will provide an exhaustive analysis of these factors to explain precisely why the succession from Pope Benedict XVI to Pope Francis was one of the most extraordinary events in the modern history of the Catholic Church.

Section 1: The Pontificate of Benedict XVI: A Scholar on the Throne of Peter

To comprehend the significance of the resignation, one must first understand the man who made the decision and the immense pressures that defined his time in office. Joseph Ratzinger was not a conventional pastoral figure; he was a scholar and theologian of the first rank, and his papacy was marked by a series of profound institutional crises that would test the limits of any leader.

1.1 The Theologian Pope

Long before he became Pope Benedict XVI, Joseph Ratzinger had established himself as one of the Catholic Church's most formidable intellectuals.11 Born in Bavaria, Germany, in 1927, his life was shaped by his academic pursuits and deep theological convictions.1 He was ordained a priest in 1951 and quickly embarked on a distinguished academic career, teaching dogma and theology at several German universities.1 During the landmark Second Vatican Council (1962-1965), he served as a key theological advisor, or

peritus, contributing to some of its most important documents.12

In 1981, Pope John Paul II appointed him Prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, the Vatican office responsible for safeguarding Catholic doctrine.6 For nearly a quarter of a century in this role, he was the Church's chief theological guardian, a figure known for his intellectual rigor and defense of traditional teachings.1 When he was elected pope on April 19, 2005, at the age of 78, he was one of the oldest popes to assume the office.13 His election was widely seen as a choice for continuity with his predecessor, a decision to place a man of profound intellect and doctrinal clarity on the Throne of Saint Peter.6 His chosen episcopal motto,

Cooperatores veritatis ("Cooperators of the truth"), perfectly encapsulated his life's work and the intended tone of his pontificate.6

1.2 A Papacy Beset by Crises

Despite his intellectual prowess, Benedict's papacy was not defined by serene theological reflection. Instead, he inherited and was forced to confront a series of debilitating institutional crises that placed immense "physical and mental demands" on his leadership.2 These challenges formed the turbulent backdrop against which his decision to resign must be understood.

First and foremost was the global clerical sexual abuse crisis, which exploded with full force during his pontificate.13 As Prefect, Ratzinger was already intimately familiar with the scale of the problem. As pope, he took unprecedented steps to address it. He became the first pontiff to meet with victims of abuse and personally apologize for their suffering.16 Under his authority, the Church defrocked hundreds of offending priests between 2011 and 2012.16 However, the crisis also ensnared him personally. Allegations arose that he had mishandled cases during his time as Archbishop of Munich from 1977 to 1982, a charge the Vatican denied but which shadowed his papacy and followed him even into retirement.13

The second major crisis was the "Vatileaks" scandal of 2012, an episode that represented a profound institutional and personal betrayal.16 Benedict's own butler, Paolo Gabriele, leaked a trove of the pope's personal and confidential documents to Italian journalist Gianluigi Nuzzi.16 The resulting book,

His Holiness: The Secret Papers of Benedict XVI, exposed a Vatican Curia rife with infighting, corruption, and financial mismanagement. The leaks revealed internal power struggles and efforts to undermine the pope's authority, painting a picture of a dysfunctional and divided administration.16 For a reserved scholar like Benedict, this public airing of internal strife was a devastating blow, often cited by observers as a potential "straw that broke the camel's back".16

Finally, his pontificate was plagued by persistent financial controversies surrounding the Vatican Bank, officially known as the Institute for Works of Religion (IOR). The bank's historical lack of transparency drew intense scrutiny from Italian and European authorities. In 2010, Italian police seized millions of dollars in Vatican funds over suspicions of money laundering.16 Benedict attempted to institute reforms by establishing a new Financial Intelligence Authority, but these efforts were hampered by an entrenched bureaucracy. The situation culminated in early 2013, just before his resignation, when Italian banks ceased processing electronic payments within the Holy See, briefly relegating the Vatican to a cash-only state—a moment of profound institutional embarrassment.16

The relentless pressure of these converging crises—moral, administrative, and financial—formed the landscape of Benedict's papacy. The role of the modern pope, as demonstrated by these events, had evolved far beyond that of a spiritual leader and teacher. It had become a high-stakes executive position requiring the constant management of a global institution under siege. The official reason Benedict would give for his resignation was his "deteriorating strength" and inability to meet the "physical and mental demands of the papacy".2 These demands were not abstract; they were the concrete, grinding realities of the abuse scandal, the Vatileaks betrayal, and the struggle for financial reform. These crises did not directly force his resignation, but they magnified the frailty he felt, creating the conditions where stepping down became not an act of surrender, but a logical and responsible choice. In this light, his resignation can be interpreted as his final, and perhaps most profound, teaching. It was a magisterial act that implicitly argued the modern papacy is no longer a role that can be sustained by prayer and suffering alone, but requires a level of physical and mental stamina that must be honestly assessed. This fundamentally reframes the office from a lifelong martyrdom to a ministry with human limits.

Section 2: The Renunciation: A Decision of "Full Freedom"

The decision to resign was not a sudden impulse but a conclusion reached after a period of deep reflection. The rationale presented to the world evolved over time, beginning with a formal, institutional justification and later supplemented by a deeply personal and human explanation that shed new light on the physical toll of the papacy.

2.1 The Official Proclamation

On February 11, 2013, Pope Benedict XVI gathered the cardinals for what they believed was a routine meeting to approve the canonization of new saints.17 Instead, speaking in Latin, he delivered his historic announcement. The news was broken to the world by journalist Giovanna Chirri, who happened to be one of the few reporters present who understood the classical language.2 In his formal statement, Benedict, then 85 years old, cited his advanced age as the primary factor. He declared that after repeatedly examining his conscience before God, he had "come to the certainty that my strengths... are no longer suited to an adequate exercise of the Petrine ministry".17

He elaborated on the unique demands of the modern era, stating that "in today's world, subject to so many rapid changes and shaken by questions of deep relevance for the life of faith, in order to govern the barque of Saint Peter and proclaim the Gospel, both strength of mind and body are necessary".17 He humbly admitted that this strength had "deteriorated in me to the extent that I have had to recognize my incapacity to adequately fulfill the ministry entrusted to me".17 The Vatican spokesman, Father Federico Lombardi, quickly clarified that the decision was not prompted by any specific medical illness but rather by a natural "decline of strength" associated with old age, a decision that had "matured over the past few months".17 Benedict critically noted that his decision was made in "full freedom," a specific canonical requirement for a valid papal resignation.2

2.2 The Deeper, Personal Rationale

While the official announcement focused on a general decline, a more specific and intimate reason emerged nearly a decade later, shortly before his death. In a letter dated October 28, 2022, Benedict revealed to his official biographer, Peter Seewald, that the "central motive" for his resignation was chronic insomnia.19 This condition, he explained, had "accompanied me uninterruptedly since World Youth Day in Cologne" in August 2005, just a few months after his election.19

He wrote that the "strong remedies" prescribed by his personal physician had initially been effective, but they eventually "reached their limits" and were no longer able to guarantee his fitness for the office.19 The turning point came during his apostolic journey to Mexico and Cuba in March 2012. He recounted a serious incident where, on the morning after the first night, he discovered his handkerchief was "totally soaked with blood." He concluded, "I must have bumped into something in the bathroom and fallen".19 A surgeon was able to treat the injury so that it was not publicly visible, but the event had profound consequences.19

Following this incident, his new physician urged a reduction in his sleeping medication and insisted that on future trips abroad, he should only appear in public during the mornings.19 Benedict realized that these medically necessary restrictions "could only apply for a short time".19 With the next major international event, World Youth Day in Rio de Janeiro, scheduled for July 2013, he knew he would no longer be able to "cope" with its rigorous demands. He therefore planned his resignation to take effect in early 2013, ensuring that a "new pope" would be in place to travel to Brazil.19

2.3 Dispelling Conspiracy

This later revelation served a dual purpose. It not only provided a more complete picture of his reasoning but also acted as a definitive rebuttal to the persistent conspiracy theories that had swirled since his announcement. Rumors of blackmail, pressure related to the Vatileaks scandal, or financial mismanagement had continued to circulate despite official denials.2 Peter Seewald stated that he felt "obliged to publish the decisive detail" from the pope's medical history precisely to "finally put the conspiracy theories and erroneous speculations to rest".19 Benedict's letter reaffirmed what he had stated from the beginning: his resignation was a personal and free decision based on his health, made for the good of the Church.17

The two-stage nature of this explanation—a formal, institutional statement at the time of the event, followed by a specific, deeply personal medical reason revealed years later—appears to have been a deliberate approach. The initial announcement protected the dignity of the papal office at a moment of unprecedented vulnerability, framing the decision in theologically sound terms of service and capacity. The later revelation, shared in the final months of his life, protected the legacy of the man, grounding the abstract "deterioration of strength" in the concrete and painful reality of chronic illness and physical injury. In doing so, it offered a powerful and humanizing testament to the physical toll of the papacy. This dual justification effectively created two layers of precedent. The first is a theological precedent: a pope can and should resign if he conscientiously determines he lacks the requisite strength for the office. The second is a human precedent: the papacy is a physically demanding role with inherent risks, and it is an act not of cowardice but of profound humility to acknowledge one's human limitations.22 This makes future resignations more plausible and less scandalous.

Section 3: The Extraordinary Nature of the Act: A Historical Perspective

The modern world had become accustomed to the image of a pope reigning for life, often through periods of profound illness, as exemplified by Benedict's own predecessor, John Paul II. Benedict's decision to step down was therefore a radical break with this tradition, an act whose extraordinariness is best understood when placed in its proper historical context.

3.1 A Rupture with Modern Precedent

The most immediate reason Benedict's resignation was so shocking was its sheer rarity. It was the first time a pope had resigned in nearly 600 years.1 Since the resignation of Gregory XII in 1415, every one of Benedict's predecessors had held the office from the day of their election until the day of their death.2 The papacy had come to be seen as a unique vocation, a spiritual fatherhood that, like natural fatherhood, did not end until life itself did. Benedict's act shattered this modern convention and reintroduced the idea of the papacy as an office—the Petrine ministry—that could be relinquished if its holder was no longer capable of fulfilling its duties.

3.2 Distinctions from Historical Resignations

A deeper historical analysis reveals that even the few precedents for papal renunciation are poor comparisons, highlighting the truly unique nature of Benedict's decision. The circumstances of the most cited examples were products of crisis and political necessity, not personal conscience.

The last pope to resign, Gregory XII in 1415, did so under extreme duress to resolve the Western Schism.2 This was a catastrophic period in Church history, lasting nearly four decades, during which two, and eventually three, men all claimed to be the legitimate pope, dividing the loyalties of European nations and threatening to permanently fracture Western Christendom.26 Gregory's resignation was not a personal choice made in serene reflection; it was a negotiated political settlement brokered by the Council of Constance, which pressured all claimants to step down to allow for the election of a single, universally recognized pontiff to reunify the Church.8 His act was one of statesmanship to end a crisis, not one of personal discernment about his physical capacity.

The only other clear historical precedent for a voluntary resignation was that of Pope Celestine V in 1294.2 Celestine, born Pietro di Murrone, was an elderly hermit-monk renowned for his piety who was elected pope as a compromise candidate after the College of Cardinals had been deadlocked for over two years.25 Wholly unsuited for the administrative and political complexities of the papacy, he was quickly overwhelmed and manipulated by secular rulers.25 Recognizing his own incompetence, Celestine famously issued a formal decree confirming that a pope had the right to resign, and then promptly exercised that right himself after only five months in office, hoping to return to his life of solitude.25 His was a resignation born of a profound mismatch between the man and the office. Benedict XVI, by contrast, was the ultimate Vatican insider—a highly competent theologian and administrator who had served at the highest levels of the Church for decades. His decision was not about incompetence but about the effects of age on his competence.

3.3 The Canonical Foundation

While historically rare, the possibility of a papal resignation is explicitly provided for in the Church's modern Code of Canon Law. The precedent established by Celestine V in 1294 was eventually codified.27 Canon 332, §2 of the 1983 Code states: "If it should happen that the Roman Pontiff resigns his office, it is required for validity that the resignation is made freely and properly manifested, but not that it is accepted by anyone".2 Benedict, a man deeply versed in Church law, meticulously fulfilled these requirements. His announcement was made publicly before the College of Cardinals, and he repeatedly stressed that the decision was made in "full freedom," ensuring its canonical validity.2 His action was therefore not a violation of Church law but the modern activation of a long-dormant provision. The following table provides a clear comparative analysis, visually demonstrating the unique character of Benedict's renunciation.

Pope

Year of Resignation

Stated Reason / Context

Nature of Decision

Outcome

St. Celestine V

1294

Lack of competence; desire to return to eremitic life.25

Voluntary, personal

Imprisoned by his successor; established canonical right to resign.27

Gregory XII

1415

To end the Western Schism and reunify the Church.8

Political necessity; pressured by Council.27

Schism resolved; lived out life as a cardinal bishop.8

Benedict XVI

2013

Deteriorating strength due to advanced age and health (insomnia).17

Voluntary, conscientious

Became "Pope Emeritus"; set modern precedent for non-crisis resignation.6

This comparison makes the central argument clear: Benedict's act was of a different category entirely from its historical predecessors. It was the first time in history that a fully competent, long-serving pope had voluntarily resigned due to a personal, conscientious assessment of his own age-related limitations, free from the external pressures of schism or political collapse.

Section 4: The Emergence of the "Pope Emeritus": Navigating Uncharted Territory

Benedict's resignation created an immediate and unprecedented canonical and theological problem: what to call, how to dress, and where to house a retired pope. The solution, the creation of the "Pope Emeritus," was an improvisation that, while solving the immediate logistical issues, introduced a new and ambiguous element into the life of the Church.

4.1 The Creation of a Title

The concept of a "Pope Emeritus" did not exist in Church law or tradition before 2013. The title was created "on the fly" in the hectic weeks between Benedict's announcement and his departure.9 The term "emeritus" is a Latin adjective meaning "retired" or "having completed one's service".31 It is a common honorific in academia and is also used within the Church for retired diocesan bishops, who become, for example, the "Archbishop Emeritus" of their former see.32 Benedict XVI himself chose to adopt this style, becoming "His Holiness Benedict XVI, Pope Emeritus".2 This decision was a practical solution to an unprecedented situation, but it was one made without deep theological preparation or canonical debate.

4.2 The Symbols of a Continued Presence

The choices made regarding Benedict's post-resignation status created a powerful and, for some, troubling symbolism of a continued papal presence within the Vatican.

• Name and Title: He continued to be addressed as "His Holiness" and retained his papal name, Benedict XVI, rather than reverting to his birth name, Joseph Ratzinger.2

• Attire: He continued to wear the distinctive papal white cassock. It was a simpler version, without the short shoulder cape (pellegrina) and the formal red papal shoes, but the color white is universally and exclusively associated with the reigning pontiff.33 One theological justification offered was that the papacy, like the episcopacy, could be seen as a form of spiritual ordination that is never fully lost, and just as retired bishops retain their emblems, so too could the retired pope.33

• Residence: Perhaps most significantly, after a brief two-month stay at the papal summer residence of Castel Gandolfo, he took up permanent residence in the Mater Ecclesiae Monastery, a small convent located within the Vatican Gardens.1 This placed him just a short walk from his successor, making his physical presence a constant reality within the heart of the Church.

4.3 A Life of Prayer and Study

Upon his resignation, Benedict promised to live a life "hidden from the world," dedicated to prayer and reflection for the Church.2 By all accounts, he adhered to this promise in his daily life. His routine became monastic, structured around morning Mass, the Liturgy of the Hours, reading, listening to classical music, and maintaining correspondence.33 He largely ceased writing new books but would occasionally dictate letters or author essays on topics of theological importance.33 He received occasional visitors but lived a quiet, secluded life until his death on December 31, 2022, at the age of 95.1

Despite the personal sincerity of his retirement, the improvisation of the "Pope Emeritus" role created a lasting institutional challenge. The Catholic Church's ecclesiology—its theological understanding of its own structure—is fundamentally monarchical, built on the principle of a single, unifying head: the Bishop of Rome, whose authority is unique and indivisible. The existence of a man still called "His Holiness Benedict XVI," still dressed in white, and still living in the Vatican, created a visual and symbolic duality, regardless of his actual lack of governing power. This established a new, undefined entity within the Church's hierarchy. Some theologians argued that a more appropriate title would have been "Bishop of Rome Emeritus" to reduce this ambiguity and more clearly signal the end of his unique papal ministry.9 The ad-hoc solution to a personal situation has thus become a lasting and potentially destabilizing institutional precedent, leaving a host of unresolved questions about the boundaries, powers, and limitations of the role for any future papal resignations.

Section 5: The Francis Pontificate and the Shadow of a Predecessor

The election of Cardinal Jorge Mario Bergoglio as Pope Francis on March 13, 2013, inaugurated the unprecedented era of "two popes".6 While the personal relationship between the two men was marked by respect, their coexistence created a new political dynamic within the Vatican, with Benedict's presence, however silent, casting a long shadow over the new pontificate.

5.1 A Relationship of Public Respect and Private Support

Publicly, the relationship between Francis and Benedict was a model of fraternal respect. On their first meeting, they prayed side-by-side, with Francis famously insisting, "We are brothers".7 Francis frequently referred to Benedict as a "wise grandfather at home," expressing gratitude for his prayerful presence within the Vatican.34 He made it a point to visit his predecessor on important occasions, and Benedict made rare public appearances at major events early in Francis's pontificate, such as the creation of new cardinals and the canonization of Popes John Paul II and John XXIII.13

Beyond public gestures, Benedict was also a source of crucial private support for his successor. Pope Francis later revealed that Benedict "always defended me".36 He recounted an instance where a group of conservative cardinals, upset with Francis's views on civil unions, went to Benedict's monastery to "practically put me on trial." Benedict, Francis said, "was not shaken... He listened to them, one by one, calmed them down and explained everything".36 This private solidarity demonstrated a deep respect for the office and the man who held it.

5.2 Ideological Divides and Factionalism

Despite this personal cordiality, the two men represented starkly different pastoral and theological visions for the Church. Benedict's papacy was seen as traditionalist, emphasizing doctrinal clarity, liturgical continuity with the past, and the intellectual defense of the faith in a secularizing Europe.1 Francis, in contrast, emerged as a radical pastoral reformer, emphasizing mercy over rules, prioritizing the world's poor and marginalized, and adopting a simpler, less monarchical style.10

This ideological gap, combined with Benedict's continued physical presence in the Vatican, created what one historian called a "recipe for schism".10 Conservative factions within the Church, who were unsettled by Francis's reforms and his perceived doctrinal ambiguity, began to view the silent Pope Emeritus as their symbolic standard-bearer.10 Benedict became an unwilling focal point for opposition to the reigning pope, a figurehead for those who preferred his more traditional approach.

5.3 Controversial Interventions

Though he had promised to remain "hidden," on a few highly publicized occasions, Benedict's writings were perceived as direct interventions in the affairs of the Church, actions that seemed to undercut his successor and fuel the narrative of a divided Vatican.

• The 2019 Essay on Sexual Abuse: In April 2019, Benedict released a 6,000-word essay on the clerical abuse crisis. In it, he blamed the scandal on the sexual revolution of the 1960s, the collapse of Catholic moral theology, and the presence of "homosexual cliques" in seminaries.10 This analysis was seen by many as being in direct tension with Pope Francis's diagnosis, which centered on clericalism—the abuse of power and status by clergy—as the root cause of the crisis.10

• The 2020 Book on Priestly Celibacy: In January 2020, a book was published defending the tradition of priestly celibacy that listed Benedict XVI as a co-author alongside the conservative Cardinal Robert Sarah.36 The book's publication was extraordinarily ill-timed, appearing at the very moment Pope Francis was deliberating on a proposal from the Synod on the Amazon to ordain married men as priests in remote regions. The intervention was widely viewed as a direct and public attempt by the former pope to pressure the current pope on a live and sensitive decision.9 The controversy was so intense that Benedict's secretary, Archbishop Georg Gänswein, later asked for Benedict's name to be removed as co-author, but the damage was done.36

These episodes demonstrated the inherent difficulty of the "Pope Emeritus" role. Despite Benedict's personal intentions to remain silent and supportive, his mere existence provided a powerful, alternative pole of authority. In the modern, hyper-mediatized Church, it proved impossible for a former pope to be truly "hidden." His presence, his silence, and especially his rare words were inevitably interpreted and instrumentalized within the ongoing political and theological debates of the Church. This suggests that any future papal resignation will require a much more rigorously defined protocol for the emeritus role to mitigate the risk of creating a rival court or a symbol of opposition.

Conclusion: The Enduring Legacy of an Extraordinary Decision

The succession of Pope Francis following the pontificate of Pope Benedict XVI stands as a watershed moment in the history of the modern Catholic Church. It was an event made extraordinary not merely by the act of resignation itself, but by the unique convergence of its motivation, its consequences, and its lasting implications. Benedict's decision was a radical departure from centuries of tradition, a deeply personal act of conscience that has had profound and enduring institutional effects.

First, the resignation fundamentally humanized the papacy. By publicly acknowledging that his physical and mental strength were no longer adequate for the immense demands of the modern Petrine ministry, Benedict dismantled the modern myth of the pope as a figure who must reign until death, regardless of personal capacity.11 His later, more intimate revelation about his struggle with chronic insomnia grounded this decision not in abstract theology but in the painful, relatable reality of human frailty. In doing so, he has made resignation a viable and honorable option for his successors, reframing the office as a ministry with human limits rather than a lifelong sentence of martyrdom.

However, this personal act of humility introduced a period of unprecedented institutional ambiguity. The ad-hoc creation of the "Pope Emeritus" title and the subsequent cohabitation of a reigning and a retired pope within the Vatican created a symbolic duality that the Church had never before navigated.9 While the personal relationship between Francis and Benedict was one of mutual respect, Benedict's continued presence—however quiet—inevitably became a rallying point for factions opposed to his successor's reforms.10 This dynamic revealed underlying tensions within the Church and created an unresolved ecclesiological question about the status and role of a retired pontiff that remains a challenge for the future.

Ultimately, the succession from Benedict to Francis was extraordinary because a single, conscientious decision irrevocably changed the perception of the papacy itself. It was a transition born not of death, but of a humble recognition of human limitation. This act set a powerful precedent and posed fundamental questions about the nature of authority, service, and tradition in the Catholic Church—questions with which theologians, canon lawyers, and the faithful will be grappling for generations to come.

Works cited

1. Pope Benedict XVI - Biography, accessed on October 6, 2025, https://www.biography.com/religious-figures/pope-benedict-xvi

2. Resignation of Pope Benedict XVI - Wikipedia, accessed on October 6, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Resignation_of_Pope_Benedict_XVI

3. Pope's shock resignation: reaction from Rome - YouTube, accessed on October 6, 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ps1tKrUcptE

4. Pope's resignation: reaction around the world | Pope Benedict XVI - The Guardian, accessed on October 6, 2025, https://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/feb/11/pope-resignation-reaction-around-world

5. In his own words: Pope's views on resigning changed over time - VOA, accessed on October 6, 2025, https://www.voanews.com/a/in-his-own-words-pope-s-views-on-resigning-changed-over-time/8003697.html

6. Pope Benedict XVI - Wikipedia, accessed on October 6, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pope_Benedict_XVI

7. A timeline of Pope Emeritus Benedict XVI's life | PBS News, accessed on October 6, 2025, https://www.pbs.org/newshour/world/a-timeline-of-pope-emeritus-benedict-xvis-life

8. en.wikipedia.org, accessed on October 6, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Papal_renunciation

9. The myth of the self-regulating institution of 'pope emeritus ..., accessed on October 6, 2025, https://www.ncronline.org/opinion/guest-voices/myth-self-regulating-institution-pope-emeritus

10. Pope Francis and Pope Benedict's Hidden Rivalry Led to a Rift, accessed on October 6, 2025, https://www.biography.com/religious-figures/a64540403/pope-francis-and-pope-benedict-relationship

11. Pope Benedict's impact on the Church | Archdiocese of Mobile, accessed on October 6, 2025, https://mobarch.org/news/pope-benedicts-impact-on-the-church

12. Pope Benedict XVI | USCCB, accessed on October 6, 2025, https://www.usccb.org/popes/pope-benedict-xvi

13. Benedict XVI | Biography, Pope, Papacy, Resignation, Legacy, & Facts | Britannica, accessed on October 6, 2025, https://www.britannica.com/biography/Benedict-XVI

14. Who Was Pope Before Francis? Full Timeline of Catholic Church's Popes, accessed on October 6, 2025, https://www.newsweek.com/who-pope-before-francis-full-timeline-catholic-church-popes-2036219

15. en.wikipedia.org, accessed on October 6, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Resignation_of_Pope_Benedict_XVI#:~:text=He%20cited%20his%20deteriorating%20strength,been%20too%20much%20for%20him.

16. Why Pope Benedict XVI Resigned - Biography, accessed on October 6, 2025, https://www.biography.com/religious-figures/a64540677/why-pope-benedict-resigned

17. Citing Health Reasons, Pope Benedict Announces he will Resign | USCCB, accessed on October 6, 2025, https://www.usccb.org/offices/general-secretariat/citing-health-reasons-pope-benedict-announces-he-will-resign

18. Pope Benedict XVI Cites Advancing Age and Poor Health for Resignation | PBS News, accessed on October 6, 2025, https://www.pbs.org/newshour/nation/pope-benedict-xvi-to-step-down-at-end-of-february

19. Biographer reveals the reason for Pope Benedict's resignation: insomnia, accessed on October 6, 2025, https://www.americamagazine.org/faith/2023/01/27/pope-benedict-insomnia-resignation-244617/

20. Biographer: Letter From Benedict XVI Reveals the 'Central Motive' for His Resignation, accessed on October 6, 2025, https://www.ncregister.com/cna/biographer-letter-from-benedict-xvi-reveals-the-central-motive-for-his-resignation

21. Pope Benedict XVI suffered from insomnia, exhaustion, which led to his resignation, papal biographer says - Boston Pilot, accessed on October 6, 2025, https://www.thebostonpilot.com/article.php?ID=194110

22. Against the idea that Pope Benedict XVI "ran away" by renouncing the papacy. - Reddit, accessed on October 6, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/Catholicism/comments/13l0802/against_the_idea_that_pope_benedict_xvi_ran_away/

23. The unintended consequences of Pope Benedict XVI's resignation - YouTube, accessed on October 6, 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bdaTdm28We4

24. The modern popes: Get to know the 11 popes before Francis - OSV News, accessed on October 6, 2025, https://www.osvnews.com/the-modern-popes-get-to-know-the-11-popes-before-francis/

25. Office Hours: Pope Benedict XVI and the strange history of papal resignations, accessed on October 6, 2025, https://news.illinoisstate.edu/2013/02/office-hours-pope-benedict-xvi-and-the-strange-history-of-papal-resignations/

26. Who was the most recent pope to resign and why? What is the significance of being given a title instead of being called 'Pope'? - Quora, accessed on October 6, 2025, https://www.quora.com/Who-was-the-most-recent-pope-to-resign-and-why-What-is-the-significance-of-being-given-a-title-instead-of-being-called-Pope

27. Papal Resignations and Elections: A Beginner's Guide - Pints of History, accessed on October 6, 2025, https://pintsofhistory.com/2013/03/08/papal-resignations-and-elections-a-beginners-guide/

28. Which Other Popes Have Resigned? - History News Network, accessed on October 6, 2025, https://www.historynewsnetwork.org/article/which-other-popes-have-resigned

29. Papal resignations: the case of Celestine V | Lillian Goldman Law Library, accessed on October 6, 2025, https://library.law.yale.edu/news/papal-resignations-case-celestine-v

30. History professor says Pope's resignation allowable thanks to one man – Rhody Today, accessed on October 6, 2025, https://www.uri.edu/news/2013/02/history-professor-says-popes-resignation-allowable-thanks-to-one-man/

31. What does Pope Emeritus mean? - In Pure Spirit, accessed on October 6, 2025, https://inpurespirit.com/5037/what-does-pope-emeritus-mean/

32. Emeritus - Wikipedia, accessed on October 6, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emeritus

33. A look back: Benedict XVI's life as pope emeritus – Catholic World ..., accessed on October 6, 2025, https://www.catholicworldreport.com/2023/01/07/a-look-back-benedict-xvis-life-as-pope-emeritus/

34. www.ewtnvatican.com, accessed on October 6, 2025, https://www.ewtnvatican.com/articles/papacy-of-francis-and-the-presence-of-benedict-xvi-5105#:~:text=And%20Francis%20said%20that%20he,he%20was%20through%20and%20through.

35. The Papacy of Francis and the Presence of Benedict XVI - EWTN Vatican, accessed on October 6, 2025, https://www.ewtnvatican.com/articles/papacy-of-francis-and-the-presence-of-benedict-xvi-5105

36. Pope Francis on his relationship with Benedict: 'He always defended me' | USCCB, accessed on October 6, 2025, https://www.usccb.org/news/2024/pope-francis-his-relationship-benedict-he-always-defended-me

37. A Historic Departure: Reflections on Benedict XVI's surprise decision to resign, accessed on October 6, 2025, https://www.americamagazine.org/faith/2013/02/20/pope-benedict-resignation-why-154806/