The Annihilation of the Self in the Divine Reality: A Study of Fana in Sufi Mysticism

The Sufi Quest for Haqiqah (The Divine Reality)

The mystical tradition within Islam, known as Sufism (Arabic: at-Taṣawwuf), represents an experiential quest for the direct, personal realization of God.1 It is an esoteric path focused on spiritual purification (

tazkiyah), the cultivation of divine love, and the internalization of Islamic principles to achieve a state of heightened consciousness of the Divine Presence.1 The ultimate aim of the Sufi, or seeker (

murid), is not merely adherence to religious law but a profound return to the primordial state of purity and natural disposition, known as fitra, in which the human being was created.1 This journey is fundamentally an experiential one, seeking to uncover a deeper, essential Self that exists beyond the superficial personality and lives in perfect harmony with the Source of all Life.4 The doctrine of

fana, or the annihilation of this superficial self, stands as a pivotal and defining stage on this path, a necessary gateway to the ultimate goal: the realization of Haqiqah, the Divine Reality.

Defining Sufism: The Esoteric Heart of Islam

Sufism is best understood as the inner or mystical dimension of Islam.3 Its practitioners hold that the path originates directly from the Quran and the strict emulation of the life and character of the Prophet Muhammad, through whom the seeker’s spiritual connection to the Divine is established and fortified.1 The practice of Sufism is a way of life in which this deeper, essential identity is discovered and lived. This essential Self possesses capacities for awareness, creativity, and love that far transcend those of the ordinary, ego-driven personality.4 The spiritual lineage of Sufi orders is traced back to the Prophet through a continuous chain of transmission (

silsila), initiated by the pledge of allegiance (bay'ah) given by his companions. By giving this pledge to a legitimate Sufi master (shaykh), the seeker is believed to be connecting to this spiritual chain, thereby establishing a direct link to the prophetic source of divine knowledge.1 More than a set of beliefs, Sufism is an intensified, intentional expression of

Islam in its original meaning of "submission"—the harmonization of the individual will with the Divine Will.4

Tawhid: The Bedrock of Sufi Metaphysics

The unshakeable foundation of all Islamic thought, and particularly of Sufism, is the principle of Tawhid—the absolute, uncompromising Oneness of God.3 For the Sufi,

Tawhid is not simply a theological doctrine to be affirmed but an ontological reality to be experienced directly. The entire universe and all of creation are viewed as manifestations (tajalliyat) or self-disclosures of this singular Divine Being. The influential Andalusian master Ibn Arabi articulated this through the metaphor of a single, ungraspable reality being reflected in countless mirrors; the created beings are these mirrors, possessing no independent existence apart from the reality they reflect.6 This perspective radically reorients the seeker's understanding of self and reality. Everything other than God is seen as a contingent "shadow of the True Existence," having no essential reality in itself.7

This profound understanding of Tawhid transforms the concept from a creedal statement into the central existential problem and its ultimate solution. From this vantage point, the perception of a separate, autonomous self—the ego or nafs—is not merely a psychological error but a form of hidden polytheism (shirk), the one unforgivable sin in Islam.8 The illusion of a self that exists independently of God is the fundamental veil that separates the human being from the Divine Reality. Consequently, the entire Sufi path, with its rigorous disciplines and contemplative practices, can be understood as a sophisticated and practical methodology for realizing

Tawhid experientially. The journey is a process of systematically dismantling the psychological and ontological structures that uphold the illusion of separateness. The state of fana, the annihilation of this false self, is the climactic moment in this process, where the "lie" of a separate existence is extinguished, allowing the "Truth" (Haqiqah) of Divine Oneness to be directly and indubitably perceived. As the early Sufi master Shebli declared, “The Sufi sees nothing except God in the two worlds”.4

The Hierarchy of the Path: Shari'a, Tariqa, and Haqiqah

The Sufi journey toward this ultimate realization is traditionally conceptualized as a progression through three distinct yet inseparable stages, often depicted as concentric circles leading to a central point.6

1. Shari'a (The Exoteric Law): This is the outermost circle and the indispensable foundation of the path. It comprises the body of Islamic law derived from the Quran and the Sunnah (prophetic tradition), governing all aspects of life. For the Sufi, the Shari'a is the divinely ordained framework of ethics and worship within which the spiritual life must be lived. There can be no authentic spiritual progress without strict adherence to its principles.

2. Tariqa (The Esoteric Path): This is the inner path, the specific methodology of a Sufi order designed to guide the seeker from the outward observance of the law to its inner reality. The Tariqa is the "way" or the "path" itself, involving a set of spiritual disciplines, contemplative practices, and the crucial guidance of a shaykh.3 It is the practical application of Sufi teachings aimed at purifying the heart and transforming the self.

3. Haqiqah (The Mystical Truth/Reality): This is the central point, the goal of the journey. Haqiqah is the direct, unmediated experience of the Divine Reality, the ultimate Truth that the Shari'a points to and the Tariqa leads to.6 It is the profound, experiential knowledge (
   ma'rifa) that is unveiled to the seeker at the culmination of their journey, after the ego-self has been "annihilated" in fana.6 In this state, the secrets of the divine essence are revealed, and the seeker understands reality "as it is," not through the distorting lens of the ego but through the clarity of the divine light.10

This hierarchical structure demonstrates that Sufism is not an alternative to mainstream Islam but its deepest and most intensive expression. The path begins with the body (actions in Shari'a), moves through the heart (purification in Tariqa), and culminates in the spirit's vision of the Real (Haqiqah).

The Veil of the Self: Understanding the Nafs

Central to Sufi psychology and the entire project of spiritual transformation is the concept of the nafs. The nafs is the ego-self, the individual consciousness that says "I." In its unpurified state, it is the primary obstacle, the veil that conceals the Divine Reality from human perception. The spiritual path, therefore, is fundamentally a process of tazkiyat an-nafs, the purification and transformation of the self. This inner struggle is famously known as the "Greater Jihad" (al-jihad al-akbar), considered more arduous and more important than any external conflict.12 Understanding the nature of the

nafs and its developmental stages is the essential prerequisite for comprehending the meaning and necessity of its annihilation in fana.

The Nafs: The Enemy Within

In Sufi teachings, the nafs is identified as the lower self, the seat of all base instincts, carnal desires, and negative character traits such as pride, greed, envy, and anger.12 It represents the "animal and satanic nature" within a person and is considered the "worst enemy you have".12 The Quran itself warns of the

nafs that "incites to evil" (an-nafs al-ʾammārah).12 The Sufi path turns the seeker's attention inward, teaching that the primary battle is not against external foes but against this internal tyranny of the ego.4 The great poet Rumi vividly captures its deceptive nature, warning that "the

nafs has a rosary and a Koran in its right hand, and a scimitar and dagger in its sleeve," highlighting its ability to cloak destructive impulses in the guise of piety.12

Sufi psychology often presents a tripartite model of the human inner constitution, wherein the nafs is the lowest principle. Above it are the Qalb (the spiritual heart) and the Ruh (the pure spirit). The Qalb is not the physical organ but the seat of spiritual perception and gnosis (ma'rifa). It functions as a crucial intermediary, and its primary task is to gain mastery over the unruly nafs and orient the entire being towards the light of the Ruh.14 The journey towards

fana is thus the process of purifying the Qalb so that it ceases to be a mirror for the desires of the nafs and becomes instead a polished mirror reflecting the divine attributes of the Ruh.

The Seven Stages of the Nafs's Transformation

The Sufi tradition maps the "Greater Jihad" as a progressive ascent through seven distinct levels or stations of the nafs. This framework provides a detailed and sophisticated model of spiritual-psychological development, showing that spiritual growth is not a random or instantaneous event but a gradual process of maturation. Each stage has its own distinct characteristics and challenges, and the seeker's task is to master the lessons of each level in order to ascend to the next.12 This model functions as a spiritual-psychological map of the soul, indicating that the capacity for higher spiritual states is contingent upon the developmental stage of the self. A soul dominated by the lower impulses of the first stage is psychologically incapable of the profound surrender required for

fana. The path is thus a form of spiritual therapy designed to mature the soul to the point where it becomes a fitting receptacle for the ultimate mystical experience.

The seven stages are as follows:

LevelArabic NameEnglish TitleQuranic Reference/BasisCore CharacteristicSpiritual Task/Challenge1an-Nafs al-AmmāraThe Commanding SelfSurah Yusuf 12:53Dominated by base instincts, desires, and egoism; incites to evil and is unconscious of its own faults.12To awaken the conscience and recognize the destructive nature of one's actions; to begin the struggle against base impulses.2an-Nafs al-LawwāmaThe Accusing SelfSurah al-Qiyama 75:2The conscience awakens; the self recognizes its faults, feels regret and guilt, and accuses itself for its transgressions, but still struggles with sin.12To move from regret to sincere repentance (Tawba) and to strengthen the will to resist temptation consistently.3an-Nafs al-MulhimaThe Inspired SelfSurah ash-Shams 91:8The seeker finds genuine pleasure in spiritual practices. The heart is inspired with a desire for virtue, compassion, and service. A dangerous stage prone to spiritual pride and delusion.13To cultivate humility and gratitude, to distinguish true divine inspiration from the ego's subtle deceptions, and to seek the guidance of a master.4an-Nafs al-MuṭmaʾinnaThe Serene/Peaceful SelfSurah al-Fajr 89:27The soul becomes tranquil, firm in faith, and at peace. It has overcome major spiritual diseases and finds contentment in the remembrance of God.12To maintain a state of constant awareness and remembrance of God, moving from contentment to a deeper state of surrender.5an-Nafs ar-RaḍiyyaThe Pleased SelfSurah al-Fajr 89:28The self is completely content with God's decree, accepting both hardship and ease with equal gratitude. It recognizes that all power and action originate from God alone.15To dissolve all personal preference and resistance, achieving a state of perfect satisfaction with the Divine Will in all circumstances.6an-Nafs al-MarḍiyyaThe Pleasing SelfSurah al-Fajr 89:28A state of profound inner unity. The self is now pleasing to God, and God is pleased with it. The seeker acts as a harmonious reflection of Divine attributes, experiencing the world as a unified whole.15To move from passive acceptance to active participation as an instrument of Divine Mercy and Love in the world.7an-Nafs aṣ-Ṣāfiyya/al-KāmilaThe Pure/Perfect SelfN/AThe highest stage. The illusion of a separate self is completely transcended. The individual has realized that "there is nothing but God" and lives in perfect unity, their will indistinguishable from God's Will.12To embody the reality of Tawhid fully, becoming a perfect servant and a locus of divine manifestation for the guidance of others.

Fana - The Doctrine of Annihilation

At the apex of the spiritual journey, after the arduous purification of the nafs through its many stages, the seeker arrives at the threshold of fana. This doctrine is the cornerstone of Sufi mystical theosophy and represents one of the most profound and often misunderstood concepts in the study of mysticism. It is the point where the path of self-purification culminates in the experience of self-annihilation, a mystical death that is the gateway to a higher form of life.

Etymology and Core Meaning: "To Die Before You Die"

The Arabic term fana (فناء) literally translates to "passing away," "ceasing to exist," "extinction," or "annihilation".2 In the Sufi lexicon, it is most famously encapsulated in the prophetic hadith and Sufi dictum, "Die before you die" (

mūtū qabla an tamūtū).19 This paradoxical command makes a crucial distinction: it does not refer to physical death but to a spiritual, mystical death. It is the death of the false, limited, ego-self—the

nafs—which has been the object of the "Greater Jihad" throughout the spiritual path.8

The theological and ontological basis for this concept is often rooted in the Quran, particularly Surah Ar-Rahman (55:26-27): "All things upon it [the earth] are in a state of fana (annihilation). And there remains the Face of your Lord, Possessor of Majesty and Honor".2 This verse establishes a fundamental cosmic principle: everything in creation is transient and perishing, while only the Divine Reality is permanent and abiding.

Fana for the mystic is the experiential realization of this truth in the core of their own being. They taste the perishing nature of their own limited selfhood in the face of the eternal reality of God. This insight radically redefines the conventional meanings of "life" and "death." The ordinary state of ego-consciousness, which people consider "life," is, from the Sufi perspective, a form of spiritual death—a state of being veiled from, and thus dead to, the one true Life, which is God. The mystical "death" of the ego in fana is, paradoxically, the only gateway to attaining true, eternal Life (baqa) in God. This reveals that fana is not a nihilistic concept aimed at non-existence, but a soteriological one. It is not about becoming nothing, but about ceasing to be the false thing (the separate ego) in order to realize and participate in the true Reality.

The Nature of the Experience: Beyond the Intellect

Fana is not an intellectual concept to be grasped or a philosophical theory to be debated; it is an experiential state, a "tasting" (dhawq) of a reality that transcends ordinary consciousness.24 Those who have described it speak of a state of overwhelming spiritual bliss, where the individual becomes so completely absorbed and lost in the contemplation of God that they are rendered insensible to everything else—the world, its objects, and even their own self.21

This experience is often likened to a state of spiritual intoxication (sukr), a term used by the "intoxicated" school of Sufism to denote the overwhelming rapture that accompanies the vision of the Divine.8 In this state, the seeker's ordinary faculties of perception and reason are suspended. They may be spoken to but not hear, touched but not feel, because their entire consciousness is consumed by the Divine Presence.25 The Japanese scholar Toshihiko Izutsu described it as "the total nullification of the ego-consciousness, when there remains only the absolute Unity of Reality".9 It is the complete dissolution of the

illusion of being a separate, independent entity, a moment of supreme clarity in which the seeker realizes their utter contingency and God's absolute reality.

Annihilation of What? Attributes, Will, and Consciousness

It is crucial to understand precisely what is annihilated in the state of fana. Sufi masters are careful to clarify that it is not the annihilation of the seeker's essential being or individual essence. Rather, it is the annihilation of the limiting and false attributes associated with the lower self (nafs).19

1. Annihilation of Attributes: The process involves the "passing away of the attributes of the lower self," such as pride, desire, and self-centeredness, which are replaced by the reflection of divine attributes.19 The seeker is stripped of their human imperfections.

2. Annihilation of Will: Fana entails the complete surrender of the individual will to the Divine Will. The seeker ceases to be an independent agent driven by personal desires and becomes a pure vessel for the will of God. As early texts describe, "he goes forth from his own qualities and enters into the qualities of God... he goes forth from his own will... and enters into the will of God".19

3. Annihilation of Consciousness of Other-than-God: At its peak, fana is the "annihilation of all remembrance of other" than God.19 This includes the annihilation of the consciousness of oneself. Imam Al-Ghazali provides a masterful description of this state, explaining that the heart becomes so utterly immersed in the Remembered (God) that it becomes heedless even of its own act of remembrance. To be conscious of the fact that one is annihilated is itself a veil and a blemish, for true
   fana is to be completely absent from oneself and all of creation, present only with God.25

In this profound state of "self-oblivion," the boundaries of the ego dissolve, and the seeker experiences the unitive reality that was previously veiled by the illusion of a separate self.

The Path of Annihilation: Stations, States, and Practices

The sublime state of fana is not an accidental occurrence nor is it attainable through mere intellectual speculation or wishful thinking. It is the culmination of a structured, disciplined, and arduous journey on the Sufi path, the Tariqa. This path provides the seeker (murid) with a map, a methodology, and a guide to navigate the treacherous terrain of the inner world. It is a path that balances rigorous personal effort with a profound reliance on divine grace, emphasizing that while the seeker must strive with all their being, the ultimate unveiling is a gift from God.

The Indispensable Guide: The Role of the Shaykh

At the heart of the Tariqa is the relationship between the seeker and the spiritual guide, known as the Shaykh or Murshid.5 The

shaykh is a master who has already traversed the path, reached a state of spiritual realization, and is authorized by his own master to teach, initiate, and guide others.5 The seeker formally enters the path by giving a pledge of allegiance (

bay'ah) to the shaykh. This act is of profound significance, as it establishes a spiritual bond that connects the seeker to the silsila, the unbroken chain of spiritual transmission that extends back through generations of masters to the Prophet Muhammad himself.1 Through this connection, the seeker receives the spiritual blessings (

baraka) and teachings of the lineage.

The shaykh serves multiple functions: he is a teacher of the esoteric meanings of the Quran and Sunnah, a spiritual physician who diagnoses and prescribes remedies for the diseases of the nafs, and a role model who embodies the prophetic character.27 His guidance is considered essential for navigating the subtle pitfalls of the spiritual journey, especially during advanced stages like the

Nafs al-Mulhima (The Inspired Self), where the ego can create powerful delusions of spiritual attainment.17

A crucial stage on the path is known as Fana fil-Shaykh (Annihilation in the Guide). This is an advanced state where the disciple, through intense love and concentration, becomes so absorbed in the spiritual reality of the master that their own ego begins to dissolve. The disciple's heart becomes a mirror for the master's heart, and they begin to see through his eyes and perceive with his spiritual insight.28 This is not a form of personality worship but a profound spiritual technique. Because the

shaykh is himself annihilated in the Prophet and in God, Fana fil-Shaykh serves as a necessary gateway, preparing the seeker for the higher annihilations in the Prophet (Fana fil-Rasul) and, ultimately, in God (Fana fillah).28

The Map of the Journey: Maqamat (Stations) and Ahwal (States)

The Sufi path is not an amorphous journey but a structured progression through a series of spiritual stations (maqamat) and the experience of transient spiritual states (ahwal). This framework reveals a sophisticated understanding of the interplay between human effort and divine grace. The path is neither one where salvation is earned by effort alone, nor one where effort is irrelevant due to predestination. Instead, it posits a synergistic relationship: the seeker must diligently build the vessel of the soul through the discipline of the stations, but it is only divine grace that fills that vessel with the spiritual wine of the states. Fana can be seen as the ultimate state where the vessel itself dissolves into the wine.

• Maqamat (Stations): These are stable, enduring spiritual stages on the path that are "earned" or acquired through the seeker's sustained effort, discipline, and spiritual struggle (mujahadah).33 They represent the development of virtuous character traits and a permanent transformation in the seeker's being. While the number and order can vary between different Sufi orders, the classical stations typically include:

• Tawba (Repentance): A sincere turning away from sin and toward God.

• Wara' (Watchfulness): Scrupulous piety, avoiding anything that is doubtful.

• Zuhd (Renunciation/Asceticism): Detachment from worldly desires and possessions.

• Faqr (Spiritual Poverty): The realization of one's absolute dependence on God.

• Sabr (Patience): Enduring hardship without complaint, as a test from God.

• Tawakkul (Trust in God): Complete reliance on God for all of one's needs.

• Rida (Contentment): Joyful acceptance of God's will and decree.36

• Ahwal (States): These are transient, temporary spiritual moods or experiences that are not earned through effort but are bestowed upon the seeker as gifts of divine grace.33 They are flashes of insight and tastes of the Divine Reality that descend upon the heart, giving the seeker encouragement and a glimpse of the goal. These states cannot be summoned or retained by the seeker's will. They include:

• Khauf and Raja' (Fear and Hope): Fear of God's justice and hope in His mercy.

• Shawq (Longing): Intense yearning for the Divine Beloved.

• Uns (Intimacy): A feeling of closeness and familiarity with God.

• Mahabbat (Love): The all-consuming love for God that becomes the primary motivator on the path.35

The diligent traversal of the maqamat purifies the soul, making it a suitable receptacle for the divine effulgence of the ahwal. These states, in turn, provide the spiritual nourishment and motivation needed to persevere in the difficult work of the stations, ultimately preparing the soul for the overwhelming state of fana.

The Engine of Transformation: Core Spiritual Practices

The progression through the stations and the receptivity to the states are facilitated by a set of core spiritual practices that form the engine of the Sufi Tariqa.

• Dhikr (Remembrance): This is the central and most fundamental practice in Sufism, based on the Quranic injunction to "remember God often".1
  Dhikr is the constant remembrance of God, most often through the rhythmic repetition of His names (such as "Allah") or sacred phrases (such as "La ilaha illa'llah," "There is no god but God").1 It can be performed vocally (
  jahri) or silently (khafi), individually or in a group setting.39 The goal of
  dhikr is to polish the mirror of the heart, cleansing it of the rust of worldliness and forgetfulness (ghaflah). The practice aims to move the remembrance from the tongue to the heart, until it becomes a continuous, effortless state where the Remembered (God) completely overwhelms the consciousness of the rememberer, leading directly to the threshold of fana.25

• Muraqaba (Contemplation/Meditation): This is the practice of spiritual watchfulness and deep contemplation. The seeker focuses their mind and heart on God, contemplating the divine reality and striving to maintain a constant awareness of the Divine Presence.1 It is a method for quieting the incessant chatter of the
  nafs and opening the inner eye of the heart to perceive spiritual truths.

• Sama (Spiritual Audition): Certain Sufi orders, most famously the Mevlevi order founded by the disciples of Rumi, utilize sama—listening to spiritual poetry, music, and in some cases, engaging in ritualized dance like the famous "Sufi whirling".1 The purpose of these practices is to induce a state of spiritual ecstasy (
  wajd) in which the seeker can transcend the limitations of the ego and experience a taste of divine union. The repetitive, circular motion of the whirling dervishes is a symbolic imitation of the planets orbiting the sun, representing the soul's journey from the multiplicity of creation to the unity of the Divine Source, abandoning the nafs to focus solely on God.1

• Asceticism (Zuhd): This involves the conscious renunciation of worldly pleasures and attachments in order to focus the heart exclusively on God.39 It is not a rejection of the world as inherently evil, but a strategic detachment from its distractions. Practices such as fasting (especially beyond the obligatory month of Ramadan), night vigils for prayer (
  tahajjud), and periods of intensive spiritual retreat (khalwa) are employed to weaken the grip of the nafs and purify the soul.39

Through the combination of the master's guidance, the structured ascent through the maqamat, and the diligent application of these spiritual technologies, the seeker's soul is gradually prepared for the transformative and grace-given experience of fana.

Scholastic Debates and Interpretive Divides

The concept of fana, dealing as it does with an ineffable mystical experience at the limits of human consciousness, has naturally given rise to a rich and complex history of interpretation within the Sufi tradition. It is not a monolithic doctrine but has been understood and articulated in different ways by various masters and schools of thought. The most significant and enduring interpretive divide is between the so-called "sober" and "intoxicated" schools of Sufism. This debate is not merely a historical or theological disagreement; it reflects two fundamental and perennial modes of mystical consciousness itself: the apophatic, which emphasizes God's absolute transcendence and the otherness of the mystical encounter, and the kataphatic, which emphasizes God's immanence and the experience of unitive identity.

The "Sober" School of Baghdad: Fana as Witnessing (Mushahadah)

The "sober" school, primarily associated with the Sufis of Baghdad in the 9th and 10th centuries, and epitomized by the master Al-Junayd al-Baghdadi, championed the virtue of spiritual sobriety (sahw).8 This perspective was later systematized and integrated into mainstream Islamic theology by the great scholar Abu Hamid al-Ghazali. For this school, the ultimate goal is a state of clear, lucid "witnessing" (

mushahadah) of the Divine Reality, not a loss of consciousness or an ontological fusion with it.19

In this interpretation, fana is understood as the annihilation of the seeker's self-will and the obliteration of their consciousness of being a separate, independent agent. It is the realization of Fana fi al-Tawhid, the passing away in the affirmation of Divine Oneness, which means recognizing experientially that God is the sole, true Agent in the universe.19 The seeker's actions, will, and attributes are seen to "pass away" into God's Actions, Will, and Attributes. However, this school rigorously maintains the ontological distinction between the Creator and the created. Al-Ghazali, for example, is adamant that the experience of union is a "total identification with the divine essence, not a total integration".41 He and others explicitly condemned interpretations that suggested incarnation (

hulul) or ontological fusion (ittihad).8 In the state of

fana, the slave remains a slave and the Lord remains the Lord; the profound change is in the slave's perception, who now sees all of reality through the lens of God's absolute agency and unicity.26 The experience is one of God's self-unveiling (

kashf) to the purified heart of the servant.19

The "Intoxicated" School of Khorasan: Fana as Union (Ittihad)

In contrast, the "intoxicated" school, associated with mystics from the Khorasan region of Persia such as Abu Yazid al-Bistami and later, most famously, Mansur al-Hallaj, emphasized the overwhelming, ecstatic experience of spiritual intoxication (sukr).8 Their experience of

fana was so all-consuming that it seemed to dissolve the very distinction between the human and the Divine, leading to ecstatic utterances (shathiyat) that scandalized the exoteric religious authorities.

Al-Bistami is reported to have exclaimed in a state of ecstasy, "Subhani! Ma a'dhama sha'ni!" ("Glory be to Me! How great is My majesty!"), and al-Hallaj was famously executed for his public declaration, "Ana'l-Haqq" ("I am the Truth," with al-Haqq being one of the names of God).19 From the perspective of these mystics, at the peak of

fana, the individual ego is so completely annihilated and effaced that the speaker is no longer the human individual but God Himself speaking through the human locus.8 This interpretation points towards a total union (

ittihad), a merging of essences where the duality of lover and Beloved, worshipper and Worshipped, is momentarily obliterated in the intensity of the unitive experience.8

The Synthesis of Ibn Arabi: Wahdat al-Wujud (The Oneness of Being)

Centuries later, the Andalusian master Muhyi al-Din ibn Arabi (d. 1240), known as al-Shaykh al-Akbar (the Greatest Master), provided a profound metaphysical framework that can be seen as a philosophical synthesis of these two poles. His doctrine of Wahdat al-Wujud (the Oneness of Being or Unity of Existence) posits that there is, in reality, only one Being—God. All of creation, the entire cosmos of multiplicity, is nothing but the self-manifestation (tajalli) or outward radiance of that one, singular Being.42

From this non-dual perspective, the problem of "union" is reframed entirely. Fana is not the process of one independently existing being (the human) uniting with another independently existing Being (God). Rather, it is the annihilation of the illusion that the human being ever had a separate, independent existence in the first place. Ibn Arabi argues that the very premise that one must "cease to exist" in order to know God is a subtle form of polytheism (shirk), because it presupposes two distinct existences to begin with.43

For Ibn Arabi, fana is the experiential realization of one's own essential non-existence as a separate entity and the simultaneous realization of God's sole and all-encompassing Existence. As one of his treatises states, "Thou art not thou: thou art He, without thou... it is meant by it that thou never was nor wilt be... Thou art He, without one of these limitations".43 This framework provides a language to articulate the unitive experience of the "intoxicated" mystics while preserving the absolute transcendence of the Divine Essence, a cornerstone of the "sober" school. The "I" that speaks in al-Hallaj's "I am the Truth" was, in its ultimate reality, never separate from the one Divine "I" that is the ground of all being. The debate, from this perspective, is not about which experience is more valid, but about the adequacy of the theological and philosophical language used to interpret an ineffable reality that transcends the subject-object duality of ordinary thought.

The Poetics of Annihilation: Symbolism in Sufi Literature

The experience of fana is, by its very nature, ineffable. It lies beyond the categories of rational thought and the descriptive capacity of literal language. To convey the nature of this state and the path leading to it, Sufi masters and poets have historically turned to a rich and evocative symbolic language. Metaphor, allegory, and poetry become the primary vehicles for communicating the truths of the heart. This symbolic language is not merely decorative; it functions as a sophisticated pedagogical system, with each major metaphor highlighting a different essential dimension of the fana experience: its volitional, epistemological, and ontological aspects.

The Lover and the Beloved: The Erotics of Divine Union

Perhaps the most pervasive symbolic framework in Sufi literature is that of love (ishq). The relationship between the seeker and God is depicted as a passionate, all-consuming love affair between the lover ('ashiq) and the Divine Beloved (ma'shuq).4 This is not a gentle, placid affection but a burning, transformative fire that demands the lover's complete and utter self-surrender. The path is a journey of being "purified by love, free of themselves and their own qualities and fully attentive to the Beloved".4

In this context, fana is the ultimate consummation of divine love. It is the moment when the lover, in their intense yearning, is completely annihilated and absorbed into the reality of the Beloved.4 The distinction between human love (

ishq-e majazi) and divine love (ishq-e haqiqi) is crucial; the former is seen as a bridge or a reflection of the latter, a training ground for the heart to learn the art of selfless devotion that will ultimately be directed towards God.39 This framework emphasizes the

volitional dimension of fana: it is a state that is actively sought, driven by an intense and passionate desire for union with the Divine.

The Moth and the Flame: The Yearning for Self-Immolation

A more specific and powerful metaphor that captures the dynamic of this loving self-surrender is that of the moth and the flame.44 The moth, representing the soul of the seeker, is irresistibly drawn by its nature to the light of the candle flame, which symbolizes the Divine Reality. The moth's journey towards the flame is fraught with danger, yet its love for the light is so overwhelming that it willingly sacrifices its own existence for a moment of union.

The 12th-century Persian poet Fariduddin Attar, in his allegorical masterpiece The Conference of the Birds, tells a famous story that illustrates the different levels of knowing through this metaphor. A group of moths gathers to learn the truth of the candle flame. The first moth flies near the castle and reports back on the light it saw from a distance. The wise moth among them dismisses this as mere secondhand information. A second moth flies closer, touching the flame with its wings and feeling its heat, and reports back on this direct sensory experience. The wise moth again dismisses this as incomplete knowledge. Finally, a third moth, overwhelmed with love, throws itself completely into the flame. It is consumed, its body becoming incandescent and indistinguishable from the flame itself. The wise moth, observing from afar, declares, "This moth alone understands that to which he has attained. None other knows it".44

This allegory masterfully illustrates the epistemological dimension of fana. It contrasts theoretical knowledge (hearing about God), rational or sensory knowledge (perceiving God's attributes in creation), and the ultimate, unitive knowledge (ma'rifa) that comes only through the complete annihilation of the self. True spiritual knowledge is not informational but participatory and transformative; one must "be burned by God" to truly know God.44

The Drop and the Ocean: Dissolution into the Source

While the moth and flame metaphor emphasizes the active, loving sacrifice of the self, the metaphor of the drop and the ocean highlights the ontological shift that occurs in fana.7 The individual soul, in its state of separation, is like a single drop of water—finite, limited, and defined by its boundaries. The Divine Reality is the vast, boundless ocean.

Fana is the moment the drop falls back into the ocean.

In this dissolution, the drop does not cease to exist in an absolute sense. Rather, it loses its limited, separate identity and partakes in the infinite reality of the ocean. Its boundaries are erased, and it becomes indistinguishable from the whole. This metaphor powerfully conveys the idea of transcending limitation to gain infinitude, of sacrificing the finite ego to realize the infinite Self.7 It speaks directly to the experience of the dissolution of boundaries and the realization of being an inseparable part of a single, all-encompassing reality. Rumi employs this imagery when he has the Divine Beloved say to the seeker, "I am the sea, and you are a single fish; don't strand yourself on dry land; I am your clear sea".48

Rumi's Vision: The Alchemy of Transformation

No poet has explored the depths of fana with more passion and profundity than Jalal al-Din Rumi. For Rumi, annihilation is never presented as a grim or nihilistic end, but as a joyful and necessary stage in a cosmic process of spiritual alchemy and evolution.23 He uses the metaphor of a stone being transformed into a precious ruby, suggesting that the "death" of the base self is simultaneously the birth of the "fundamental Self" in its full glory.23

In one of his most famous poems, Rumi depicts fana as a series of progressive deaths and rebirths that constitute a spiritual evolution across the kingdoms of being:

"I died as a mineral and became a plant,

I died as a plant and rose to animal,

I died as animal and I was Man.

Why should I fear? When was I less by dying?

Yet once more I shall die as Man, to soar

With angels blest; but even from angelhood

I must pass on: all except God doth perish.

When I have sacrificed my angel-soul,

I shall become what no mind e'er conceived." 20

This vision frames fana not as a single event but as the very dynamic of spiritual growth. Each "death" is an annihilation of a lower, more limited form of existence, which allows for a rebirth into a higher, more expansive state of being, culminating in a reality that transcends all imaginable forms, in the direct presence of God. For Rumi, annihilation is the secret of eternal life and endless becoming.

From Annihilation to Subsistence: The State of Baqa'

The Sufi spiritual journey does not end with the ecstatic self-effacement of fana. While fana is the apex of the ascent to God, it is a penultimate, not the final, station. Many Sufi masters have insisted that fana alone is a negative and incomplete state, a dissolution that must be followed by a positive reconstitution.2 The crucial and necessary counterpart to

fana (annihilation) is the state of baqa (بقاء), which means "subsistence," "permanence," or "abiding" in God.8 If

fana is the mystical death of the ego, baqa is the spiritual rebirth into a new, abiding life in and through God.42 This dialectic of

fana and baqa is central to the Sufi ideal of the perfected human being and provides the path with its unique ethical and world-engaging dimension.

Baqa: The Positive Pole of Annihilation

After the seeker is "awakened" from the all-consuming state of fana, they enter the station of baqa.11 In this state, having been annihilated from their own limited, human attributes, they are revived and made to subsist by the eternal attributes of God.2 Their individual will, having passed away into the Divine Will, is restored to them, but it now functions in perfect harmony with the Divine Will. The secrets of the Divine Reality (

Haqiqah), which were overwhelming in fana, are now revealed to a consciousness that has been stabilized and fortified by God.2 It is the transition from the intoxicating vision of the One to the sober capacity to perceive the One in the many, and the many in the One.

This concept of returning to a state of distinction after the experience of union is what some Sufis have termed the "second separation" (farq-i thani).23 The first separation was the illusion of the ego's existence apart from God. The unitive state of

fana overcomes this. The second separation is the clear-sighted perception, within the state of baqa, of the distinction between the servant's duties and the Lord's reality, even while experiencing profound inner unity. This is the station of perfect servanthood ('ubudiyyah).

The Return to Creation: A Transformed Consciousness

Crucially, the state of baqa is not a continued withdrawal from the world but a return to it, endowed with a new, God-centered consciousness.23 The mystic who attains

baqa returns to live among people, to engage with the world, but their perception and motivation are radically transformed. They have become a pure instrument of God's plan and purpose in the world.19 A famous

hadith qudsi (a saying in which God speaks in the first person through the Prophet) is often cited to describe this state: "...My servant continues to draw near to Me with supererogatory works until I love him. And when I love him, I am the hearing with which he hears, the seeing with which he sees, the hand with which he strikes, and the foot with which he walks".45

This is the state of the "universal man" (al-insan al-kamil), the perfected human being who has realized all the latent divine potentialities within the human state and now serves as a polished mirror perfectly reflecting the divine names and attributes back into creation.46 This person embodies the bridge between the Divine and the mundane, the unseen and the seen. The ultimate goal of the Sufi path, therefore, is not a permanent escape from the world but its sanctification through the presence and actions of these perfected individuals. They return to the marketplace, but the marketplace is now perceived as a theater for divine manifestation. This creates a profoundly world-affirming mysticism, giving purpose and meaning to worldly existence as the arena in which the realized truth is to be lived, embodied, and expressed for the benefit of all creation.

The Dynamic Interplay of Fana and Baqa

For some masters, particularly Rumi, fana and baqa are not merely a linear, one-time sequence but a continuous, dynamic, and simultaneous process that occurs at every moment.23 This understanding is linked to the theological concept of "New Creation" (

khalq-i jadid), which posits that the entire universe is annihilated and recreated by God at every instant.50

From this perspective, to live the eternal Life of baqa in the ever-present "now," the mystic must be "dying at every moment" in fana.23 The state of

baqa thus preserves the reality of fana within itself. It is a continuous process of negating the false—the illusions and attachments of the ego—and affirming the Real. It is the constant "annihilation of obstacles and impediments" and the simultaneous "subsistence" of the true self in God.45 This dynamic interplay ensures that the mystic remains both utterly effaced in God and perfectly present in the world, embodying the paradox of being "absent from oneself but present with God" and, in the highest state, "present with oneself and present with God".4

Clarifying Misconceptions and Comparative Perspectives

The profound and paradoxical nature of fana has often led to significant misunderstandings and critiques, both from within and outside the Islamic tradition. Accusations of pantheism, antinomianism (the rejection of religious law), and nihilism have been leveled against Sufis who speak of annihilation and union. A clear understanding of the doctrine requires addressing these critiques from an orthodox Sufi perspective. Furthermore, placing fana in the broader context of world mysticism by comparing it with analogous concepts, such as Nirvana in Buddhism and Moksha in Hinduism, helps to illuminate its unique features and theological underpinnings.

Addressing Critiques: Pantheism, Antinomianism, and Nihilism

• Critique of Pantheism: The ecstatic utterances (shathiyat) of mystics like al-Hallaj ("I am the Truth") have been interpreted as claims of ontological fusion with God, leading to charges of pantheism (the belief that God and creation are identical) or incarnation (hulul).8

• Orthodox Sufi Response: Mainstream Sufi masters have consistently and vigorously refuted this interpretation. They insist on the absolute ontological distinction between the Creator (Rabb) and the created servant ('abd).26 The experience of union is understood as a psychological and spiritual state of overwhelming divine presence, not an ontological merging of essences.26 As Al-Sarraj clarified, God does not descend into the soul; what descends is faith in God and reverence for Him.19
  Fana does not mean the human becomes God, but that the human realizes their own nothingness and that all things subsist only through God, the sole reality.7

• Critique of Antinomianism: Another common misunderstanding is the belief that the state of fana elevates the mystic beyond the need to follow the Islamic Law (Shari'a), as they have supposedly reached a direct connection with the Lawgiver Himself.

• Orthodox Sufi Response: This view is unequivocally condemned as a grave deviation and heresy by authentic Sufi masters.7 The greatest Sufi saints are known for their meticulous observance of the
  Shari'a. The Prophet Muhammad, the ultimate model for all Sufis, remained a perfect servant of God even after the highest spiritual experiences. The ecstatic utterances of certain mystics are considered excusable on account of the overwhelming spiritual state (hal) they were in, but they are not to be taken as doctrinal precedents or used as a justification for abandoning religious duties.7

• Critique of Nihilism: The very term "annihilation" can be misconstrued as a morbid desire for self-destruction or a lapse into absolute nothingness.

• Orthodox Sufi Response: This fundamentally misreads the purpose of fana. The annihilation sought is not of existence itself, but of the false, illusory, and constricted existence of the ego. It is the negation of "something that never truly was"—the independent self—in order to affirm and experience the "fullness of Being" which is God.45 As the dialectic with
  baqa (subsistence) shows, fana is the necessary gateway to a higher, more real, and eternal form of life. It is a soteriological, not a nihilistic, doctrine.

Comparative Analysis: Fana, Nirvana, and Moksha

On the surface, the Sufi concept of fana bears a striking resemblance to the ultimate goals of other major mystical traditions, particularly Nirvana in Buddhism and Moksha in Hinduism. This comparison reveals both profound structural similarities in the mystical process across cultures and crucial metaphysical differences that define the unique character of each path.

• Phenomenological Similarities: All three concepts point to a state of liberation that involves the transcendence or dissolution of the ordinary ego-self. They are all predicated on the elimination of craving, desire, and attachment to the phenomenal world, which are seen as the sources of suffering and illusion.24 The paths to these goals often involve analogous practices of meditation, ethical purification, and mental discipline designed to "halt" the incessant activity of the mind and ego.24 In this sense,
  fana, Nirvana, and Moksha all represent a form of "ego death" that leads to a state of profound peace and freedom.51

• Metaphysical and Theological Differences: The crucial distinctions lie in the metaphysical framework within which this experience of ego-dissolution is interpreted. The content of the ultimate reality that is realized is fundamentally different in each tradition.

1. Nature of the Ultimate Reality: In Sufism, the self is annihilated in God (fana fillah). The ultimate reality, Allah, is a personal, living, conscious Being who is both transcendent and immanent. The experience is one of passing away into the presence of this Divine Beloved. In stark contrast, the ultimate goal in Theravada Buddhism, Nirvana, is the "extinguishing" of the "fires" of greed, hatred, and delusion, leading to the realization of Anatta (no-self) and the cessation of the cycle of rebirth (samsara). It is not a union with a divine being but a release into an unconditioned state. In Mahayana Buddhism, this is further articulated as the realization of Śūnyatā (Emptiness), the understanding that all phenomena are devoid of inherent, independent existence.19 In Hinduism,
   Moksha is liberation from samsara and is often understood, particularly in the influential school of Advaita Vedanta, as the realization that the individual soul (Atman) is and always has been identical with the ultimate, impersonal reality of Brahman, a non-dual, universal consciousness.51

2. The State That Follows: The Sufi dialectic of fana and baqa (subsistence in God and return to the world) is a distinctive feature. While the Mahayana Buddhist ideal of the Bodhisattva involves a compassionate return to the world to aid other beings, the theological basis is different. The Sufi in the state of baqa understands themself as a conscious instrument and locus of manifestation for the attributes of a personal God. Nirvana is often described as a final, irreversible state of release, an "extinguishing" from which there is no return to the cycle of becoming.24

3. The Role of Divine Love: While devotional paths (bhakti) are prominent in Hinduism and compassion (karuna) is central to Buddhism, the Sufi emphasis on ishq—a passionate, burning, and often eroticized love for a personal Divine Beloved—as the primary driving force for the annihilation of the lover in the Beloved gives the experience of fana a distinctly relational and affective character that is unique.4

This comparative analysis reveals a crucial point for the study of mysticism: while the psychological structure of the mystical experience (such as ego-dissolution) may be phenomenologically similar across different traditions, the content and interpretation of that experience are profoundly shaped by the foundational metaphysical and theological doctrines of each path. The experience of "emptiness" is interpreted as Śūnyatā within a Buddhist framework, while a phenomenologically similar experience is interpreted as the overwhelming Presence of the One Real Being (God) within a Sufi framework. Therefore, the concepts are not interchangeable, as the metaphysical context that imbues them with meaning is fundamentally distinct.

Conclusion: The Enduring Significance of Fana

The doctrine of fana, the annihilation of the self in the Divine Reality, stands as the luminous and challenging apex of the Sufi path. It is far more than a mere philosophical concept or a historical curiosity; it represents the culmination of a profound and practical system of spiritual transformation, a "death before death" that is the gateway to true, eternal life. This inquiry has sought to elucidate the multi-faceted nature of this doctrine, situating it within the broader Sufi quest for Haqiqah (the Divine Reality) and detailing the intricate path of self-purification that precedes it.

The journey begins with the foundational Islamic principle of Tawhid, the Oneness of God, which Sufism transforms from a creedal affirmation into an experiential goal. The primary obstacle to this realization is the nafs, the ego-self, whose illusion of separateness constitutes a veil between the human and the Divine. The "Greater Jihad" against this inner enemy, mapped out in the seven developmental stages of the nafs, is the essential work of the seeker. Through the rigorous disciplines of the maqamat (stations) and the grace-given tastes of the ahwal (states), under the indispensable guidance of a shaykh, the seeker's soul is polished until it is prepared for the ultimate unveiling.

Fana itself is the ineffable moment when the purified soul, driven by the fire of divine love (ishq), transcends its own limited consciousness. It is the annihilation of the false attributes, the selfish will, and the very consciousness of a separate self, resulting in a state of "self-oblivion" where only the reality of God remains. This experience, interpreted through the "sober" lens of witnessing or the "intoxicated" lens of union, and given profound metaphysical depth by thinkers like Ibn Arabi, is conveyed through the potent symbols of the lover dissolving in the Beloved, the moth consumed by the flame, and the drop merging with the ocean.

Crucially, the journey does not terminate in this void. The negative pole of annihilation is completed by the positive pole of baqa, or subsistence. In this state of spiritual rebirth, the seeker returns to the world, no longer as a prisoner of the ego, but as a conscious instrument of the Divine Will, seeing with God's sight and acting with His power. This dialectic of fana and baqa establishes a world-affirming mysticism, where the ultimate purpose is not to escape creation but to sanctify it through the presence of the perfected human being who embodies the bridge between heaven and earth.

While bearing structural resemblances to the goals of other mystical traditions like Buddhist Nirvana and Hindu Moksha, fana is uniquely defined by its theistic context: it is an annihilation in a personal, loving God, followed by a subsistence through Him. In conclusion, fana is a sophisticated and coherent doctrine of spiritual transformation, representing the experiential heart of the Sufi tradition. It is the process by which the illusion of the separate self is surrendered, allowing the seeker to realize the ultimate Truth of Divine Oneness and to live in the world as a dynamic, living testament to that Reality.

Works cited

1. Sufism - Wikipedia, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sufism

2. Fana | Meaning, Sufism, & Islam - Britannica, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://www.britannica.com/topic/fana-Sufism

3. The Role of Sufism in Islamic Spirituality: Mysticism and Practices - yantar.ae, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://yantar.ae/blog/the-role-of-sufism-in-islamic-spirituality-mysticism-and-practices

4. What is Sufism? - The Threshold Society, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://sufism.org/sufism

5. Sheikh (Sufism) - Wikipedia, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sheikh_(Sufism)

6. Exploring the Ultimate Aims of Sufism - Ghayb.com, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://ghayb.com/exploring-the-ultimate-aims-of-sufism/

7. Annihilation in God (Fana Fi'llah) - The Fountain Magazine, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://fountainmagazine.com/all-issues/2019/issue-132-nov-dec-2019/annihilation-in-god-fana-fillah

8. Doctrine of Fana and Baqa of Sufism in Shafak's The Forty Rules of Love: A Content Analysis, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://www.humapub.com/admin/alljournals/glr/papers/hreEFhLDVB.pdf

9. Fana and Pathologizing: Sufi Ego-Annihilation and James Hillman's Idea of the Suffering Soul by Michael Bogar - Depth Insights, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://www.depthinsights.com/Depth-Insights-scholarly-ezine/e-zine-issue-5-fall-2013/fana-and-pathologizing-sufi-ego-annihilation-and-james-hillmans-idea-of-the-suffering-soul-by-michael-bogar/

10. Sufism — Levels and Goal - Medium, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://medium.com/@miainsel2/sufism-levels-and-goal-bccaaa32afb6

11. Ḥaqīqah | Mysticism, Wisdom, Enlightenment | Britannica, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://www.britannica.com/topic/haqiqah

12. Nafs - Wikipedia, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nafs

13. 7 Stages of Nafs | PDF | Self-Improvement - Scribd, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://www.scribd.com/document/553184795/7-stages-of-nafs

14. Sufi psychology - Wikipedia, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sufi_psychology

15. The seven stages of self in Sufism : r/awakened - Reddit, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/awakened/comments/9zc6tw/the_seven_stages_of_self_in_sufism/

16. The 7 Stages of the Nafs: A Clear Path to Improvement - Purification of the Soul, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://purificationofthesoul.com/7-stages-of-the-nafs/

17. Explication of the Seven Levels of the Nafs - Jerrahi Order Of America, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://jerrahi.org/articles/level_nafs_adapted_ibrahim_hakki_erzurumi_ks

18. THE SEVEN STAGES OF EGO IN SUFISM - Psychopedia - Psychology Coaching And Research Training, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://psychopedia.in/the-seven-stages-of-ego-in-sufism/

19. Fana (Sufism) - Wikipedia, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fana_(Sufism)

20. Road to Sufism — Baqaa and Fana - Medium, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://medium.com/@miainsel2/road-to-sufism-baqaa-and-fana-9c29d695593b

21. What is fana in Sufism and what does Quran say about it? - Quora, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://www.quora.com/What-is-fana-in-Sufism-and-what-does-Quran-say-about-it

22. www.jstage.jst.go.jp, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://www.jstage.jst.go.jp/article/jorient1962/20/1/20_1_79/_article#:~:text=Fana'%20and%20baqa'%20are%20two,to%20each%20other%20in%20Rumi.

23. Fana' and Baqa' in Jalal al-Din Rumi - J-Stage, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://www.jstage.jst.go.jp/article/jorient1962/20/1/20_1_79/_article

24. Concept of fana : r/Sufism - Reddit, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/Sufism/comments/1l1qnad/concept_of_fana/

25. Imam Al Ghazali starts his chapter on rememberance (and the state of Fana) with the verse of the Quran, “Remember Allah much, so that you may be su - Thread from The Ghazalian @TheGhazalian - Rattibha, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://en.rattibha.com/thread/1762258829532664141

26. The right meaning of the extinction (fana') | Ahlus Sunnah Forum, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://ahlussunnah.boards.net/thread/218/right-meaning-extinction-fana

27. What is the role of the Sufi Shaykh? – Islam Answers, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://islamanswers.co.uk/question/what-is-the-role-of-the-sufi-shaykh/

28. fana' fi-murshid (fana' fi-shaykh) Annihilation in the Spiritual Guide - The Language of the Future | Sufi Terminology, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://www.almirajsuficentre.org.au/qamus/app/single/337

29. Annihilation in Spiritual Guide (Fana fi Shaikh) - Sultan-ul-Ashiqeen, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://sultan-ul-ashiqeen.com/annihilation-in-spiritual-guide-fana-fi-shaikh/

30. al-haqiqa Reality - The Language of the Future | Sufi Terminology, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://www.almirajsuficentre.org.au/qamus/app/single/447

31. Fana Fi Sheikh. An Original Sangatha - Ruhaniat.org, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://www.ruhaniat.org/index.php/major-papers/inner-life/2178-fana-fi-sheikh--an-original-sangatha

32. Spiritual Guide | Annihilation in the spiritual guide | Fana fi Shaikh - Sultan-ul-Ashiqeen, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://sultan-ul-ashiqeen.com/spiritual-guide-annihilation/

33. Maqamat - (World Religions) - Vocab, Definition, Explanations | Fiveable, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://fiveable.me/key-terms/hs-world-religions/maqamat

34. Definition Maqam - Maqam Sabar - Maqam Tawakkal - Rol | PDF | Sufism | Patience - Scribd, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://www.scribd.com/document/663688752/Definition-Maqam-maqam-sabar-maqam-tawakkal-rol

35. The Actualization of Maqamat and Ahwal in Modern Life (Study of the Naqsyabandiyah Babussalam Congregation, Langkat), accessed on October 1, 2025, https://konfrontasi.net/index.php/konfrontasi2/article/download/195/205/

36. Maqam (Sufism) - Wikipedia, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maqam_(Sufism)

37. The Concept of Love and The Basis of Its Doctrines Between Maqamat and Haal, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/352861242_The_Concept_of_Love_and_The_Basis_of_Its_Doctrines_Between_Maqamat_and_Haal

38. (PDF) The Actualization of Maqamat and Ahwal in Modern Life (Study of the Naqsyabandiyah Babussalam Congregation, Langkat) - ResearchGate, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/359299463_The_Actualization_of_Maqamat_and_Ahwal_in_Modern_Life_Study_of_the_Naqsyabandiyah_Babussalam_Congregation_Langkat

39. Sufi practices and rituals | Religions of the West Class Notes - Fiveable, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://fiveable.me/religions-of-the-west/unit-10/sufi-practices-rituals/study-guide/wcgqymgJt4vs0rjE

40. Sufism | Fana - The Contemplative Life, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://www.thecontemplativelife.org/blog/sufism-fana

41. Fana — A Sufi Therapy from Al-Ghazali's Books - Kalampedia, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://kalampedia.org/2022/03/03/fana-a-sufi-therapy-from-al-ghazalis-books/

42. THE PATH OF GNOSIS IN THE SUFI TEACHINGS OF IBN ... - Sufism, accessed on October 1, 2025, http://sufism.critstudies.calarts.edu/Ibn%20Arabi%20and%20the%20Path%20of%20Gnosis.pdf

43. What is fana (annihilation) in Sufism? Please explain it in simple words. - Reddit, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/Sufism/comments/ade8x3/what_is_fana_annihilation_in_sufism_please/

44. Moth and Flame | a Sufi Metaphor - Technology of the Heart, accessed on October 1, 2025, http://www.techofheart.com/2008/07/moth-and-flame-sufi-metaphor.html

45. Fana': Sufism's Notion of Self-Annihilation, or How Rumi Can Explain Why Nirvana is Samsara in Mahayana Buddhism | Networkologies, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://networkologies.wordpress.com/2012/05/17/fana-sufisms-notion-of-self-annihilation-or-why-nirvana-is-samsara-in-mahayana-buddhism/

46. Fana: When the ego gets annihilated - Raza Rumi, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://razarumi.com/fana-when-the-ego-gets-annihilated/

47. Reality of Annihilation or Fana' - SHAYKH.AI, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://shaykh.ai/reality-of-annihilation-or-fana/

48. Ghazal F1725 - Google Groups, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://groups.google.com/g/dar-al-masnavi/c/0eoevoNGtMw

49. Fana' and Baqa' in Jalal al-Din Rumi - J-Stage, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://www.jstage.jst.go.jp/article/jorient1962/20/1/20_1_79/_article/-char/en

50. Union With God – Al Ghazali on Fana (Annihilation of the Self) - YouTube, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zlds50PSZek

51. Toward The Highest Morality Of The Human Soul: A Study Of The Concept Fana Abdullah Al-Ansari Al-Harawi and Nibbana In Buddha, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://jurnal.uinsyahada.ac.id/index.php/multd/article/download/10639/pdf

52. A Constructivist Explanation for the Contrast between Nirvana and Fana, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://jpl.ut.ac.ir/article_73641.html?lang=en

53. Are Moksha and Fana the same thing? - hinduism - Reddit, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/hinduism/comments/1fnisz0/are_moksha_and_fana_the_same_thing/

54. What Are The Differences Between Sufism And Hinduism? - Hindu Enlightenment Journey, accessed on October 1, 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YXsXCTmOE3U