The Luminous Night: Divine Darkness, the Formless Absolute, and the Metaphysics of Negation in Sufi Mysticism

25 Nov

1. Introduction: The Paradox of the Radiant Void

The trajectory of mystical experience, across the diverse landscape of Islamic esotericism (Tasawwuf), is frequently conceptualized as an ascension from the darkness of the material world into the light of the Divine. The Qur’anic invocation to lead the believer "from darkness into light" (min al-zulumat ila al-nur) provides the archetypal framework for this spiritual journey, suggesting a linear progression from ignorance to gnosis. However, at the apogee of Sufi gnosticism—specifically within the intellectual schools of Ibn ‘Arabi, the visionary orders of Central Asia such as the Kubrawiyya, and the ecstatic poetry of the Persianate world—this binary collapses. The seeker, having traversed the illuminations of the Divine Attributes, arrives at a station where the intensity of the Divine Presence obliterates the capacity for perception, resulting in an experience of "Divine Darkness," "Black Light" (nur-e siah), or "Luminous Night."

This report investigates the phenomenology, metaphysics, and psychology of this dark experience, positing that it arises not from an absence of divinity, but from the confrontation with the formless, undifferentiated nature of the Divine Essence (Dhat) and the corresponding dissolution of the contingent self. The "dark experience" in Sufism is polysemantic and multivalent. It refers simultaneously to the psychological state of contraction (qabz), the ontological reality of the "Cloud" (al-Ama) preceding cosmic manifestation, and the visionary encounter with the "Midnight Sun" of the Essence. As the research indicates, this darkness is inextricably linked to the "formless nature of our existence".1 Because the ultimate reality of the self is rooted in the Divine Essence—which is beyond form, quality, and limitation—the return to this root requires the annihilation (fana) of the constructed, formal identity. This dissolution is experienced by the finite consciousness as a terrifying plunge into a void, a "dark night" where the familiar structures of being are dismantled, only to be reconstituted in the "survival" (baqa) of the Real.

The inquiry into this subject is not merely an academic exercise in historical theology but touches upon the deepest existential anxieties of the human condition. The "dark experience" describes the vertigo of the soul when it realizes that its "selfhood" is an illusion and that the only true existence is a Formless Reality that cannot be grasped by the rational mind. This report will explore these themes through four primary dimensions: the theological darkness of the Divine Essence (Apophatic Theology); the visionary darkness of the Black Light in Kubrawi Sufism; the psychological darkness of the "Dark Night of the Soul" and the state of Qabz; and the literary articulation of the "formless" in Sufi poetry, specifically the works of Mahmud Shabistari, Attar, and Rumi. Furthermore, we will integrate comparative perspectives from Christian and Buddhist mysticism to elucidate the universal structures of this apophatic ascent.

2. The Metaphysics of Unknowing: The Cloud and the Formless Essence

To understand the dark experience in Sufism, one must first grapple with the ontology of the Divine as understood by the "Greatest Master," Muhyiddin Ibn ‘Arabi (d. 1240). His comprehensive theosophical system explains the relationship between God and the world, centralizing the notion of the "Unity of Being" (Wahdat al-Wujud). For Ibn ‘Arabi, all existence is one, a manifestation of the underlying divine reality. God is both transcendent and immanent, yet His Essence remains forever unknowable.3 This unknowability is the primary source of the "darkness" encountered by the mystic.

**2.1 The Concept of Al-Ama (The Cloud)**

Ibn ‘Arabi utilizes the prophetic tradition concerning al-Ama (the Cloud) to describe the primordial state of the Divine "before" the creation of the cosmos. When asked by a companion, "Where was our Lord before He created the creation?" the Prophet Muhammad replied, "He was in a Cloud (al-Ama), neither above which nor below which was there any air".3

For Ibn ‘Arabi, al-Ama represents the level of the Divine Nature that corresponds to the "Breath of the All-Merciful" (Nafas al-Rahman). It is the supreme "barzakh" (isthmus) between the Absolute Non-manifest Essence (Ahadiyya) and the manifested cosmos. It is described as a "fog" or "cloud" because it obscures the sun of the Essence while simultaneously making its light bearable for creation.3 This Cloud is the locus of all potential forms, yet it itself is formless. It is the "Real through whom creation takes place" (al-haqq al-makhluq bihi).6 In this primordial state, God is absolutely undifferentiated and unknowable; He is the "invisible one of invisibilities" (ghayb al-ghuyub). To create the world, God "dyes" this cloud with light, engaging the forms of angels and the intellect, but the cloud itself remains the substrate of potentiality.3

The experience of this level of reality is inherently "dark" to the rational intellect because it precedes the differentiation of subjects and objects. In the state of al-Ama, the distinctions that make knowledge possible—knower and known, subject and predicate—are dissolved in a potentiality that is "both God and creation" and yet "neither God nor creation".5 The mystic who ascends to this station encounters the "God created in belief," realizing that all forms of God are delimitations of a Reality that is, in itself, non-delimited and thus "dark" to the defining faculty of the mind. The Ama is the pre-existent locus of timeless beginnings, an "Apophatic Horizon" where the potentialities of existence are not yet actualized, appearing to the mystic as a "dark cloud" of pure potentiality before the dawning of the light of manifestation.5

**2.2 The Dazzling Darkness (Hayra) and the Bat Metaphor**

The confrontation with this formless reality produces a state of Hayra, or metaphysical bewilderment. Unlike the confusion of ignorance, Hayra is the confusion of super-saturation. It arises when the seeker realizes that God cannot be confined to any specific form, dogma, or theological definition.8 Ibn ‘Arabi argues that guidance leads not to a fixed knowledge of God, but to "bewilderment" in God.9 As he famously stated, "Cleverness is mere opinion and bewilderment is vision".9

This bewilderment is a "dark" experience because it signifies the collapse of the intellect’s ability to categorize. The intellect (‘aql) functions by "binding" (from the root ‘-q-l, to fetter) meaning into forms. When it encounters the Infinite, it is blinded. Ibn ‘Arabi cites the Hadith: "God hides Himself behind seventy thousand veils of light and darkness. If He took away these veils, the fulgurating lights of His Face would at once destroy the sight of any creature who dared to look at it".10 Here, the "darkness" is not an absence of light, but an excess of it.

This phenomenon is often described via the metaphor of the bat (khuffash). The bat cannot see during the day not because the sun is dark, but because the sun’s light is too intense for the bat’s weak eyes.11 Similarly, the human intellect perceives the Absolute Essence as a "dark void" because its "light" is of an ontological intensity that obliterates the faculty of perception. The attributes of Wujud (Being) are infinite, and due to their unlimitedness, they cannot be distinguished from one another when considered as the Divine Essence. They are "hidden, non-manifest, just like different colors cannot be distinguished from one another when they are all united as pure light".12 The "formless nature of our existence" is thus perceived as a void or darkness precisely because it is the "Real" (al-Haqq) stripped of the comforting limitations of "thingness" (shay'iyya).1 This dazzlement leads to the realization that "only God knows God," and the human being's knowledge is a perpetual "unveiling" that never reaches a final form.14

2.3 Divine Essence vs. Divine Names

Ibn ‘Arabi distinguishes between the Divine Essence and the Divine Names (Attributes). The Names are the means by which God manifests in the world—The Merciful, The Vengeful, The Creator. These Names are "veils" over the Essence. The Essence itself is the "Mystery of Mysteries" (Ghayb al-Ghayb) and involves no self-manifestation (tajalli) in terms of form.10 While the Names provide "colored" lights (attributes) that the intellect can grasp, the Essence is the "White Light" (or Black Light) that contains all colors but shows none.

The "dark experience" occurs when the mystic moves beyond the Names to the Essence. In the Essence, "all the divine possibilities are in an essential equilibrium".15 This equilibrium appears as a void to the observer because there is no "tilt" or differentiation to grab onto. The seeker feels they are entering a "shoreless sea" where the "sense of a separate self" is dissolved "like sugar in water".16 This dissolution is the darkness of fana (annihilation), where the boundaries of the ego—which are constituted by "forms"—are erased by the formless intensity of the Essence.

The table below summarizes the key ontological levels and their relation to the experience of darkness.

Concept

Terminology

Description

Experience of Darkness

The Essence

Al-Dhat

The Absolute, Undifferentiated Godhead.

Absolute unknowability; the "Darkness of the Unknown" or "Divine Darkness."

The Cloud

Al-Ama

The "Breath of the All-Merciful"; pure potentiality.

The fog where forms are dissolved; indistinguishability; the barzakh between non-being and being.

Bewilderment

Hayra

The state of knowing that one cannot know.

The collapse of intellectual structures; "drowning" in the ocean of God; vision through "blinding."

Veils

Hijab

70,000 veils of light and darkness.

Light acts as a veil when it is too bright to see through (Dazzling Darkness); darkness acts as a veil of concealment.

Wujud

Existence/Being

Pure Being, identical with God.

Perceived as "nothing" by the intellect which only recognizes "things" (entities).

**3. The Visionary Stratigraphy: The Black Light (Nur-e Siah)**

While Ibn ‘Arabi provides the metaphysical framework for the formless darkness, the 12th-century Central Asian Sufi master Najmuddin Kubra and his successors (the Kubrawiyya) provided a phenomenological cartography of this experience through the science of "photisms" or colored lights seen during meditation (dhikr) and spiritual retreat (khalwa).17

3.1 The Kubrawi Scale of Lights

Najmuddin Kubra, known as the "Fabricator of Saints" (Wali Tarash), detailed a progression of colored lights that correspond to different levels of the soul’s purification. This system transforms the abstract metaphysics of darkness into a concrete visionary experience. The journey typically begins with "darkness," which Kubra identifies as the "darkness of nature" or the leaden weight of the unrefined ego.19 As the seeker purifies the self through alchemical transmutation, they perceive lights: red (the struggle of the heart against the ego), blue (the light of the soul), and white (superconsciousness).20

Kubra asserts that "Our method is the method of alchemy," involving the transmutation of the "leaden human being into gold, or light".17 This process is visualized as lights "blooming" between the eyebrows or spreading to cover the face. However, the trajectory does not end in white light. The Kubrawi mystics describe a higher stage characterized by "Green Light" and, paradoxically, "Black Light" (Nur-e Siah).

There is a significant theological divergence regarding which is the ultimate stage. Semnani (d. 1336), a later Kubrawi master, argued that the Green Light is the highest, representing the life of the heart and the "divine center," while the Black Light is a dangerous stage of "Divine Wrath" or the "Antagonist"—a "Luminous Night" that must be traversed but not dwelt in.20 For Semnani, the Black Light represents the "arcanum" (khafi), a stage of the subtle body, but the Green Light is the ultimate station of the "mystery" (akhfa).

However, earlier masters like Najm al-Din Razi and Lahiji, as interpreted by the scholar Henry Corbin, identify the Black Light as the supreme station.20 For them, the Black Light is not the darkness of evil or ignorance, but the darkness of the Absolute.

3.2 The Luminous Blackness and the "Man of Light"

For those who view the Black Light as the apex, this darkness is "Light within Darkness" or "Luminous Blackness" (savād-e a'zam). It represents the fana (annihilation) of the mystic’s ego in the Divine Essence.20 Henry Corbin’s analysis of the "Man of Light" in Iranian Sufism elucidates this paradox. He argues that the Black Light is the "Light of the Essence" (dhat). Just as the pupil of the eye is black yet is the locus of vision, the "Black Light" is the center of the soul where the individual "I" is obliterated in the "Thou" of the Divine.24

This Black Light is associated with the "Midnight Sun" (soleil de minuit) or the "Night of Symbols"—a realm where consciousness is so absorbed in the object of its vision that it loses self-awareness.20 Corbin writes that this experience is the "ascent out of cartographical dimensions; the discovery of the inner world, which secretes its own light".20 The Black Light signifies the "Divine Darkness" or the "Cloud of Unknowing" at the approach to the Pole.22

This resonates deeply with the "formless nature of existence." To enter the Black Light is to leave the world of "forms" (the colored lights, which represent attributes and qualities) and enter the "formless" (the Essence, which has no color/quality). Kubra describes this as the "distance of two bows" (qaba qawsayn), the threshold where the dualism of observer and observed collapses.17 The terror associated with this stage is the terror of annihilation—the realization that to "see" the Essence, one must cease to "be" a separate entity. The seeker must submit to this annihilation to be reborn in the "Green Light" of eternal life, but the passage through the Black Light is the crucible of the formless.

3.3 The Interpretation of Photisms

It is crucial to note that these colored lights are not merely hallucinations but are considered "objective realities" or "photisms" perceived by the suprasensory senses (hawass batin).19 The "Person of Light" (shakhs min nur) or the "Heavenly Partner" appears to the seeker to guide them through these luminous and dark landscapes.17 The Black Light, in particular, signals the annihilation of the ego's separate existence. As Najmuddin Kubra explains, "The black light isn't hallucination. It's the discovery that consciousness itself is luminous... in the deepest darkness we discover that we ourselves are the light we've been seeking".27 This connects the visionary experience back to the ontological reality: the darkness is the "Self" when stripped of all false attributions, revealing the Divine Light hidden within.

**4. The Phenomenology of Annihilation: Fana and the Void**

The theological and visionary encounters with darkness are underpinned by the practical spiritual methodology of Fana (Annihilation). This concept is crucial for explaining why the formless nature of existence is experienced as a "dark" trauma or trial. The user's query about the "formless nature of our existence" points directly to the Sufi doctrine that the human self has no independent reality, and realizing this lack of reality is the essence of the "dark experience."

**4.1 Deconstructing the Self (Tams, Mahw, and Fana)**

Fana is often misunderstood as simple self-destruction. In technical Sufi lexicon, it involves a graduated stripping away of the finite attributes that constitute the "form" of the human being. The process is often described using three terms:

Mahw (Effacement): The removal of habitual sins and the gross characteristics of the ego. This is the first step of purification.
Tams (Obliteration): The blotting out of the traces of the human attributes, such that the seeker no longer perceives their own actions but sees God acting through them. This is a deeper erasure of the "form" of the self.28
Fana (Annihilation): The complete cessation of the consciousness of a separate self. This is the entry into the "formless".28

In the state of Fana, the mystic loses all awareness of earthly existence and the individual ego. It is the "death before death" (mutu qabla an tamutu).28 This annihilation is necessary because, as the Sufis argue, "None sees the Truth but the Truth." Therefore, for God to be seen, the "me" must get out of the way. When the mystic approaches the formless, they experience the loss of their own boundaries. This is terrifying to the ego, which clings to form for its survival.

4.2 Attar's Seven Valleys and the Valley of Poverty

Farid ud-Din Attar, in his masterpiece The Conference of the Birds (Mantiq al-Tair), provides a narrative description of this dissolution. He describes the spiritual journey as traversing Seven Valleys, culminating in the "Valley of Poverty and Annihilation" (Faqr u Fana).

Valley of the Quest: Casting aside dogma.
Valley of Love: Reason is abandoned for fire.
Valley of Knowledge: Worldly knowledge becomes useless.
Valley of Detachment: "What is assumed to be 'reality' vanishes."
Valley of Unity: Realizing everything is connected.
Valley of Bewilderment: The seeker is entranced and perplexed, finding they know nothing.
Valley of Poverty and Annihilation: The self disappears into the universe.

In this final valley, the birds (souls) realize that they are "drop[s] sunk in the sea".31 The text states: "I am a shadow cast upon the dark / A drop sunk in the sea, and it is vain / To search the sea for that one drop again".31 This experience is "dark" because it entails the loss of all referents. In the Valley of Detachment, desire for mundane things leaves the heart, and the illusion of reality disappears. In the final valley, the boundaries of time and space vanish, and the traveler becomes timeless, existing in both the past and future, or rather, in the Eternal Now of the Formless.32

This "poverty" (faqr) is not merely material lack but ontological emptiness. It is the realization that the creature possesses nothing—not existence, not attributes, not actions. All belongs to God. To be absolutely poor is to be a void occupied entirely by the Divine.34 This connects to the "blackness of face" metaphor in Shabistari’s work, which will be discussed in the next section.

**4.3 The Gulshan-i Raz and "Blackness of Face"**

Mahmud Shabistari’s Gulshan-i Raz (Rose Garden of Mystery), written in 1317 AD, provides one of the most poignant poetic defenses of this dark experience. He famously writes: "Blackness of face in both worlds is poverty" (Savad al-wajh fi'l-darayn).35

While "blackness of face" is a Persian idiom for disgrace or shame, Shabistari inverts it to mean the highest spiritual attainment.

Metaphorical Meaning: The "face" represents the identity or the manifestation of the being.
Spiritual Meaning: To have a "black face" means that the contingent existence (the possible) has been completely overshadowed and obliterated by the Necessary Being (God). The "blackness" is the evidence that the dervish has no existence of their own; they are a void occupied entirely by the Divine.34
The Paradox: Shabistari calls this state "A bright night in the midst of a dark day".35 The "day" of the phenomenal world is actually dark (illusory) because it veils the Truth with plurality. The "night" of poverty/annihilation is actually bright (Truth) because it reveals the Unity of the Essence, even though it appears dark to the ego.34

The commentary by Lahiji on Shabistari reinforces this: the darkness is the "Very Light of Being" seen from the perspective of the annihilated self. It is the "Water of Life" found in the "Land of Darkness".36 The formless nature of our existence is this "Blackness"—we are nothing in ourselves, and recognizing this nothingness is the only way to reflect the Everythingness of God.

5. The Psychological Dimension: The Dark Night and Qabz

The metaphysical reality of formlessness manifests in the human psyche as the state of Qabz (Contraction) and the "Dark Night of the Soul." While Western mysticism (via St. John of the Cross) emphasizes the "Dark Night" as a purgative dryness, Sufism nuances this through the oscillation of Qabz and Bast (Expansion).

**5.1 Qabz (Contraction) as Spiritual Necessity**

Qabz is the state where the heart feels squeezed, desolate, and deprived of spiritual comfort. It is often likened to a spiritual depression.37 However, Sufi psychology, notably in the works of Al-Suhrawardi and Al-Hujwiri, distinguishes this from pathological depression. Qabz is a "noble spiritual state" sent by God for specific developmental purposes:

Checking the Ego: It prevents the seeker from claiming spiritual states as their own property. If the seeker were always in expansion (Bast), they might believe they control the divine flow.37
Breaking Dependence on Form: When the seeker is in Bast, they enjoy the experience of God (a form/state). God withdraws this experience to teach the seeker to love the Reality of God (the formless) rather than the consolation or the spiritual "high".37
Propelling Growth: As Rumi notes, the "contraction" is like the drawing back of a bowstring; it gathers the potential energy required for the arrow to fly into the formless. The greater the contraction, the greater the subsequent expansion.37

This "Dark Night of the Heart" 37 is a direct consequence of the soul’s interaction with the formless. Because the formless cannot be grasped, felt, or enjoyed in a sensory way, the faculties that rely on sensation (the "soul" or nafs) feel starved and terrified. The darkness is the silence of the senses in the presence of the supersensible.

5.2 The Terror of the Formless and Bayazid Bastami

The transition from form to formless is frequently accompanied by terror (hayba). This is illustrated in the story of the "Dark Night" of the Prophet Muhammad during the interruption of revelation (fatrah), which serves as a prototype for the Sufi crisis.39 It is also vividly depicted in the life of Bayazid Bastami (d. 874), the "King of Gnostics" (Sultan al-Arifin).

Bayazid is famous for his ecstatic utterances (shathiyat) such as "Glory be to Me! How great is My majesty!" (Subhani!).40 These utterances were not expressions of ego, but of fana—God speaking through the annihilated servant. However, the path to this state involved terrifying crises. Bayazid described his spiritual journey as a "shedding of the skin" like a snake. He experienced deep contractions where the Divine Presence felt like a crushing weight or a "darkness" that obliterated his human faculties. In one account, he speaks of a "darkness of the self" that had to be traversed to reach the "Light of the Self".41 The terror arises because the ego perceives the approach of the Absolute as its own death.

In the "Valley of Bewilderment" described by Attar, the wayfarer loses all reference points: "I have no idea who I am... I am not Muslim, nor heathen, nor who I am".33 This identity crisis is the psychological footprint of the formless. The user's query about the "dark experience... due to the formless nature of our existence" is precisely this: the existential vertigo that arises when the "I" realizes it has no inherent substance.

5.3 Sufi "Depression" and Healing

Contemporary Sufi healing practices acknowledge that this "spiritual depression" is often misdiagnosed as clinical depression. While clinical depression may stem from biochemical imbalances or trauma, "spiritual depression" (or the Dark Night) is a sign of the heart's longing for the formless and its dissatisfaction with the world of forms.38 The "cure" in Sufi therapy is not to remove the sadness, but to deepen it into "longing" (shawq) and "intimacy" (uns). The darkness is reframed as the "hidden face of God".43 As the Sufi saying goes, "The exact place of your pain is where the cure lies." The emptiness of the depression is the capacity (akasha) waiting to be filled by the Divine.44

6. Apophatic Theology and the "Blindness" of Insight

The Sufi approach to the dark experience aligns closely with Apophatic Theology (Negative Theology), which asserts that God can only be known by what He is not (neti neti, via negativa). This tradition, shared with Neoplatonism and Christian mysticism (Pseudo-Dionysius), emphasizes that the Divine Reality is beyond all names, forms, and definitions.45

6.1 Niffari and the Standing in Darkness

The 10th-century mystic Niffari, in his Kitab al-Mawaqif (Book of Standings), articulates a radical apophaticism that takes the dark experience to its linguistic limit. Niffari describes "standings" (mawaqif) where God holds the seeker in a presence devoid of knowledge, letters, or forms. He writes of a darkness that is "fire" to the gnostics—a standing where even the concept of "gnosis" (ma'rifa) must be abandoned.47

For Niffari, "ignorance" (in the sense of unlearning) is superior to knowledge because knowledge implies a separation (knower vs. known). The formless reality demands a "Holy Ignorance" or a "learned ignorance" where the seeker stands in the dark, silent before the Real. He writes, "The Knower seeks a proof; the Stander seeks the Real".47 The "standing" is a state of suspended animation in the void, where the seeker is "neither in the world nor out of it," consumed by the immediate presence of the Divine that allows for no reflection or description.49

6.2 The Bat Metaphor Redux

Returning to Ibn ‘Arabi’s use of the bat metaphor: The "darkness" is an attribute of the perceiver, not the perceived. The bat sees the sun as dark because its eyes are weak. Similarly, humans perceive the "Formless Existence" as non-existence or void because our "eyes" are calibrated only for forms.11

Sufism argues that this "blindness" is actually the highest vision. To be "blind" to the world of forms is to be "sighted" in the world of the Essence. Thus, the "Dark Experience" is a cognitive recalibration. The pain and darkness associated with it are the "growing pains" of developing a new organ of perception—the "Eye of the Heart" (‘ayn al-qalb)—which can see in the dark.1 This eye sees by the "Light of God," which to the uninitiated intellect appears as the "Darkness of the Unknown".51

6.3 Modern Interpretations: The "Dark Night" of the American Soul

Interestingly, modern interpretations have extended the concept of the "Dark Night" to collective and societal levels. The phrase "Dark Night of the Soul" is used to describe the collective trauma and "dehumanization" experienced in modern society, linking the spiritual void to the rise of extremism and the loss of meaning.52 This highlights the universality of the "dark experience"—it is the inevitable crisis that ensues when a consciousness (individual or collective) loses its connection to the "formless" source of meaning and becomes trapped in the rigid "forms" of ideology or materialism. Sufism offers a way to navigate this darkness not by fighting it, but by entering it to find the "Black Light" of shared humanity and divine essence.

7. Comparative Perspectives: The Void and the Shadow

The research highlights distinct parallels between this Sufi conception and other mystical traditions, reinforcing the universality of the "formless darkness."

7.1 Buddhism and Sunyata

The Sufi concept of Fana and the "formless" bears a striking resemblance to the Buddhist concept of Sunyata (Emptiness).28 Both traditions assert that the "self" has no inherent existence (Anatta in Buddhism, Faqr in Sufism). However, a critical distinction remains: Sufism posits that behind the "emptiness" of the self lies the "Fullness" (Wujud) of God.24 The Sufi void is a theophanic void—it is empty of the creature so that it may be full of the Creator. The "Darkness" in Sufism is thus a "pregnant darkness," whereas in some interpretations of Buddhism, the emptiness is the ultimate reality itself.

7.2 St. John of the Cross and Christian Mysticism

The comparison with St. John of the Cross 54 reveals a shared understanding of the "Dark Night" as a mechanism of divine union. St. John’s "Night of Sense" and "Night of Spirit" parallel the Sufi fana al-sifat (annihilation of attributes) and fana al-dhat (annihilation of essence). In both, the darkness is "safe" (en una noche oscura... estando ya mi casa sosegada) because it protects the soul from the distraction of false lights (egoic achievements). Both traditions agree that "God is darkness to the intellect" because He exceeds its capacity.55

8. Conclusion: The "Shadow" as the Gateway to the Real

The "dark experience" in Sufism, resulting from the formless nature of existence, is not a failure of spirituality but its ultimate consummation. It is the necessary consequence of a finite consciousness encountering an Infinite Reality.

The research establishes that:

Ontologically: The darkness is the "Cloud" (al-Ama) or the Essence, which appears dark/formless because it transcends the categories of the intellect.3 It is the "Breath of the All-Merciful" in its undifferentiated state.
Visionarily: The "Black Light" is the "Light of the Ipseity"—the blinding radiance of the Divine Selfhood that obliterates the human ego.17 It is the "Midnight Sun" seen by the "Man of Light."
Psychologically: The experience manifests as Qabz (contraction) and terror, stripping the self of its attachment to forms, concepts, and consolations.37 This "Dark Night" is a purgative fire that prepares the vessel of the heart.
Existentially: "Blackness of face" is the badge of true poverty (faqr), signifying that the human being has no independent existence and has merged into the formless Ocean of Being.34

Therefore, the Sufi mystic does not flee from this darkness but embraces it as the "Water of Life" hidden in the "Land of Darkness".36 As Rumi counsels, "Stop trying to be the sun and become a speck!".56 It is only by becoming a speck in the dark, formless void that the soul realizes it was never separate from the Sun in the first place. The "dark experience" is simply the shadow cast by the overwhelming proximity of the Light. The journey into the formless is a journey into the "Real," where the darkness of the self is exchanged for the Radiance of the Absolute.

9. Appendix: Key Technical Lexicon of the Dark Experience

The following table synthesizes the technical terminology used across the Sufi schools discussed in this report to describe the various nuances of the "dark" or "formless" experience.

Term

Translation

Contextual Meaning in Relation to "Darkness"

Key Source

Al-Ama

The Cloud / Blindness

The primordial, formless state of the Divine before creation; the "fog" that obscures the Essence.

Ibn Arabi 3

Nur-e Siah

Black Light

The highest visionary stage in Kubrawi Sufism; the blinding light of the Essence that appears as darkness.

Najmuddin Kubra / Corbin 17

Fana

Annihilation

The dissolution of the ego-self; the entry into the formless void of the Divine Presence.

Attar / Hujwiri 28

Qabz

Contraction

The psychological experience of spiritual dryness, depression, or darkness; the withdrawal of "formal" grace.

Al-Suhrawardi 37

Hayra

Bewilderment

The dazzling confusion of the intellect when facing the formless/infinite nature of God.

Ibn Arabi 8

Savad al-Wajh

Blackness of Face

A metaphor for spiritual poverty; the state of having no existence of one's own.

Shabistari 34

Tams

Obliteration

A stage of fana where even the traces of the human attributes are erased.

Sufi Glossaries 28

Mahw

Effacement

The removal of habitual sins; the first step in the "darkening" of the ego.

Sufi Glossaries 28

Ghayb

The Unseen / Invisible

The realm of reality beyond sensory perception; the "Darkness" of the Unknown.

General Sufi Metaphysics 3

Barzakh

Isthmus

The intermediate realm; specifically al-Ama as the isthmus between Essence and Cosmos.

Ibn Arabi 5

10. Deeper Analysis: The "Midnight Sun" and the Modern Relevance

10.1 The Paradox of the "Midnight Sun"

A recurrent image in the research is the "Midnight Sun" (soleil de minuit).20 This oxymoron perfectly encapsulates the Sufi realization regarding formlessness.

Day: Represents the world of multiplicity and forms. It is "light" to the senses but "dark" to the spirit because it veils the One.
Night: Represents the world of the Essence and formlessness. It is "dark" to the senses but "light" to the spirit because it is the One.
The Insight: The Sufi seeks the "Bright Night".36 This is not the darkness of ignorance (which is just black), but the darkness of the "Black Light"—a luminosity so intense it is perceived as night. This challenges the Western/Enlightenment association of "Light" with "Reason." In Sufism, Reason is a candle; the Essence is the Sun. When the Sun rises, the candle's light is obliterated (becomes invisible/dark). Thus, the "Enlightenment" of the Sufi is a "Darkening" of the rational faculty.

10.2 Relevance to "Formless Existence"

The user's query links the dark experience to the "formless nature of our existence." This suggests an ontological anxiety. The research supports the view that human existence is fundamentally "imaginal" or "barzakh-like" (isthmus-like).57 We exist on the boundary between Being and Non-Being.

The Cause of Darkness: The "dark experience" arises when the "imaginal" forms we cling to (our bodies, identities, roles) are revealed to be transparent/non-existent. We look for "ourselves" and find only a void.
The Sufi Resolution: The resolution is not to find a "new form," but to identify with the Void itself. By realizing that "I am nothing," the seeker realizes that "God is the only I." The darkness of the empty self becomes the Black Light of the Divine Self. As Ibn ‘Arabi states: "The universe is nothing but image, but in truth it is the Real".57 The darkness is the moment the image dissolves, and the Real is not yet fully recognized.

10.3 The "Dark Night" as Structural, Not Accidental

Finally, this report concludes that the "dark experience" is structural to the Sufi path. It is not an accident or a punishment. Because the Ultimate Reality is formless 2, any approach to It must involve the shedding of forms. Since the human ego is a structure of forms, this approach is necessarily felt as a "death" or "darkness." The "terror" described by the Kubrawi mystics or the "poverty" of Shabistari are descriptions of the structural collapse of the finite in the face of the Infinite. The "Formless" cannot be known; it can only be become through the annihilation of the knower.

Key Insight: The "Dark Experience" in Sufism is the subjective perception of the objective reality of the Absolute. It appears dark only because we are addicted to the "light" of relative forms. To the "Man of Light" who has passed through the Black Light, this darkness is the supreme radiance of the Divine Essence.

Bibliography of Concepts (Synthesized from Research Materials)

Attar of Nishapur: The Conference of the Birds (Mantiq al-Tair), specifically the Valleys of Detachment, Bewilderment, and Poverty.31
Henry Corbin: The Man of Light in Iranian Sufism, focusing on the "Black Light" and "Photisms".17
Ibn ‘Arabi: Futuhat al-Makkiyya and Fusus al-Hikam, focusing on al-Ama, Hayra, and the "Veils of Light and Darkness".1
Mahmud Shabistari: Gulshan-i Raz, focusing on the "Blackness of Face" and the "Bright Night".34
Najmuddin Kubra: Fawa'ih al-Jamal (Aromas of Beauty), focusing on the scale of colored lights.17
Niffari: Kitab al-Mawaqif, focusing on "Standing" in the dark/void.47
Suhrawardi: Awarif al-Ma'arif, focusing on Qabz and Bast.37
Bayazid Bastami: Shathiyat (Ecstatic Utterances) and the shedding of the self.40

Works cited

Metaphysical Order in Sufism | Sufi Path of Love, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://sufipathoflove.com/metaphysical-order-in-sufism/
Lover and Beloved - The Golden Sufi Center, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://goldensufi.org/article/lover-and-beloved/
The Mystical Visions of Ibn Arabi – Diana Steigerwald - Ismaili Web Amaana, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://www.amaana.org/ismaili/2014/04/ibn-arabi-diana-steigerwald/
Ibn Arabi On Imagination and The Creation Of The Universe - Ghayb.com, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://ghayb.com/2016/02/ibn-arabi-on-imagination-and-the-creation-of-the-universe/
Muhyi al-Din Ibn al-`Arabi (d. 638/1240) and his devotees on the `Ama' ("Cloud") phenomenon. | Hurqalya Publications, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://hurqalya.ucmerced.edu/node/4231
Cosmic Order in Sufism | Sufi Path of Love, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://sufipathoflove.com/cosmic-order-in-sufism/
Preliminary Outline of Ibn Arabis Cosmology, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://www.smonad.com/articles/outline_of_ibn_arabis_cosmology.php
(PDF) The honesty of the perplexed: Derrida and Ibn 'Arabi on 'bewilderment', accessed on November 25, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/31446497_The_honesty_of_the_perplexed_Derrida_and_Ibn_'Arabi_on_'bewilderment'
Words of Bewilderment… | سليمان ابن قدّيس - Weblogs at Harvard, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://archive.blogs.harvard.edu/sulaymanibnqiddees/2020/02/09/words-of-bewilderment/
Veils of Light and Darkness: Thinking Through Ibn Arabi's Bezels of Wisdom, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://parisinstitute.org/veils-of-light-and-darkness-thinking-through-ibn-arabis-bezels-of-wisdom/
Can anyone help me understand this quote from ibn arabi? : r/Sufism - Reddit, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/Sufism/comments/1e5ieu0/can_anyone_help_me_understand_this_quote_from_ibn/
Ibn Arabi on the Relationship Between God and Creation - TheCollector, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://www.thecollector.com/ibn-arabi-god-and-creation/
Ibn 'Arabi – Nothing but God (Unity of Being) - Soul from Elsewhere, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://mysoulisfromelsewhere.com/ibn-arabi-nothing-but-god-unity-of-being/
The Sufi Aesthetic Dimension - IEMed, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://www.iemed.org/publication/the-sufi-aesthetic-dimension/
The Quranic Inspiration of Ibn Arabi's Vocabulary of Love, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://ibnarabisociety.org/ibn-arabis-vocabulary-of-love-maurice-gloton/
Sufism and The Mystical Path. An Interview with Llewellyn Vaughan-Lee - Liane Buck, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://lianebuck.medium.com/sufism-and-the-mystical-path-8e3bacc6cf0e
Man of Light, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://hbayman.angelfire.com/en/manoflight.htm
Najm al-Din Kubra - Wikipedia, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Najm_al-Din_Kubra
Najm al-Din Kubra - Sufismo - La via del Cuore dell'Islam, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://sufi.it/sufismo/maestri-di-saggezza/najm-al-din-kubra/
The Light & Colors of Sufism - Steven D. Foster ~ Photographs : The Departing Landscape website, accessed on November 25, 2025, http://thedepartinglandscape.blogspot.com/2010/11/the-light-colors-of-sufism.html
Symbol of Light and Color in'Ala- al Dawla Semnani and Sayyid Muhammad Nūrbakhsh Thoughts - دانشگاه تهران, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://jrm.ut.ac.ir/article_53453.html?lang=en
The Man of Light in Iranian Sufism by Henry Corbin | Traditional Hikma, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://traditionalhikma.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/07/Man-of-Light-in-Iranian-Sufism-by-Henry-Corbin.pdf
Reality and Image in the Tafsīr of Kubrā and Rāzī - Muhyiddin Ibn Arabi Society, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://ibnarabisociety.org/reality-and-image-paul-ballanfat/
Commentary on Gulshan-i Raz | PDF | Philosophical Theories | Metaphysics - Scribd, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://www.scribd.com/document/370167624/Shams-Al-Din-Lahiji-Commentary-on-the-Secret-Garden-of-Divine-Mystery
The Black Mirror of the Pupil of the Eye: Around the Eye that Sees and Is Seen: Ibn al-ʿArabī, Bill Viola - MDPI, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://www.mdpi.com/2077-1444/14/8/994
Review of The Man of Light in Iranian Sufism by Henry Corbin | Dreamflesh, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://dreamflesh.com/review/book/the-man-of-light-in-iranian-sufism/
The Luminous Void: Sufism's Black Light Teaching - YouTube, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pR1QhT3HZJ8
Fana (Sufism) - Wikipedia, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fana_(Sufism)
BAQĀʾ WA FANĀʾ - Encyclopaedia Iranica, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/baqa-wa-fana-sufi-term-signifying-subsistence-and-passing-away/
Road to Sufism — Baqaa and Fana - Medium, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://medium.com/@miainsel2/road-to-sufism-baqaa-and-fana-9c29d695593b
The Conference of the Birds by Attar of Nishapur | by Kit Teguh | Medium, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://kit-teguh.medium.com/the-conference-of-the-birds-by-attar-of-nishapur-94f3fa43a177
The Conference of the Birds - Wikipedia, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Conference_of_the_Birds
Attar, The Conference of the Birds | World Epics - EdBlogs, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://edblogs.columbia.edu/worldepics/project/attar-the-conference-of-the-birds/
1880 (Raz) The Mystic Rose Garden | PDF | History | Religion & Spirituality - Scribd, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://www.scribd.com/doc/153875750/1880-Raz-the-Mystic-Rose-Garden
Gulshan i raz: the mystic rose garden of Sa'd ud din Mahmud Shabistari. The Persian text, with an English translation and no - The Matheson Trust, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://www.themathesontrust.org/papers/islam/gulshan-whinfield-all.pdf
Arabic Sufi Poetry | سليمان ابن قدّيس | Page 4, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://archive.blogs.harvard.edu/sulaymanibnqiddees/tag/arabic-sufi-poetry/page/4/
The Dark Night of the Heart - The Sufi Tavern, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://sufi-tavern.com/sufi-doctrine/the-dark-night-of-the-heart/
Healing Depression through Sufi Spiritual Healing - University of Sufism, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://sufiuniversity.org/sufi-healing/healing-depression-through-sufi-spiritual-healing/10445/
Spiritual Crisis of Prophet Muhammad | The experiences of 'Dark Night of the Soul' | Technology of the Heart, accessed on November 25, 2025, http://www.techofheart.com/2008/07/spiritual-crisis-of-prophet-muhammad.html
Bayazid Bastami - Wikipedia, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bayazid_Bastami
The Saint Is A Mirror - Dar-al-Masnavi, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://www.dar-al-masnavi.org/n-IV-2102.html
Sufism and mental health - PMC - PubMed Central - NIH, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3705685/
Not Knowing, Non-Being, and the Power of Nothingness - The Golden Sufi Center, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://goldensufi.org/article/not-knowing-non-being-and-the-power-of-nothingness/
Glossary - Hurqalya Center, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://hurqalyacenter.org/library/sufi-glossary/
Apophatic theology - Wikipedia, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apophatic_theology
(PDF) Apophatic Theology in the Perspective of Deconstructive Hermeneutics, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/388681161_Apophatic_Theology_in_the_Perspective_of_Deconstructive_Hermeneutics
The Aesthetics of Fanā' in al-Niffarī's Kitāb al- Mawāqif - IU ScholarWorks, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://scholarworks.iu.edu/iupjournals/index.php/jwp/article/download/5209/738/40347
Niffari – Stand at the Throne - Poetry Chaikhana, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://www.poetry-chaikhana.com/blog/2021/05/28/niffari-stand-at-the-throne/
Mystical Theology in Abu Abdollah Neffari's Al-Mawaqif and Al-Mukhatabaat, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://jml.alzahra.ac.ir/article_6452.html?lang=en
Highly Transformative Quotes On Sufism by William C. Chittick | by Senai Demirci, MD, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://medium.com/@senaidemirci/highly-transformative-quotes-on-sufism-by-william-c-chittick-d450b83b029a
Exploring the Apophatic Divinity (the Nameless God) - Daily Meditations with Matthew Fox, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://dailymeditationswithmatthewfox.org/2019/09/28/exploring-the-apophatic-divinity-the-nameless-god/
Dark night of the American soul - American Police Beat Magazine, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://apbweb.com/2022/01/dark-night-of-the-american-soul/
Fana': Sufism's Notion of Self-Annihilation, or How Rumi Can Explain Why Nirvana is Samsara in Mahayana Buddhism | Networkologies, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://networkologies.wordpress.com/2012/05/17/fana-sufisms-notion-of-self-annihilation-or-why-nirvana-is-samsara-in-mahayana-buddhism/
Dark Night of the Soul by Saint John of the Cross | Research Starters - EBSCO, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/literature-and-writing/dark-night-soul-saint-john-cross
Introduction To The Dark Night Of The Soul - TAN Direction, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://tandirection.com/pursuit-of-perfection/introduction-to-the-dark-night-of-the-soul/
Masnavi of Rumi · Rumi - Rumi quotes and Rumi Poems - Betting Sites UK, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://www.rumi.org.uk/masnawi/
The Disclosure of the Intervening Image: Ibn 'Arabi on Death - ResearchGate, accessed on November 25, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/236758739_The_Disclosure_of_the_Intervening_Image_Ibn_'Arabi_on_Death
Niffari (Muhammad ibn al-Hasan an-Niffari) - The Standing "My Time Has Come" - Poetry Chaikhana, accessed on November 25, 2025, http://www.poetry-chaikhana.com/Poets/N/NiffarianNif/StandingMy/index.html

Pieter Lamper https://www.opened-source.com